Makeup

“Real Beauty” ?

doverealbeauty.jpg
Some women love those Dove “Real Beauty” ads. Some women hate them. As for us, we’ve mostly ignored the “empowering” images of diverse women selling soap until today, when Slate ran a story on why they can’t get behind the Dove “Real Beauty” campaign.

The story includes this excerpt:

Dove’s appeal to righteous sisterhood is just another flavor of marketing. And it’s not particularly grounded in reality. Are we meant to believe that Unilever, the company that makes Dove, is a force for good? How to reconcile this notion with the ads for another Unilever product, Axe body spray, in which nearly every woman shown is a skinny, fashion-model-gorgeous nymphomaniac? (And by the way, Unilever also offers Slimfast, in case you’re not quite as happy with your body as the Dove girls are.)

Our first reaction: Ew.

Our second reaction: How cool that the Dove team doesn’t care about the conflict of interest with its parent company. Maybe they really do want to make a difference with women’s self esteem.

Our third reaction: No, back to Ew. We’re Kiehl’s fans for life.

Comments

avatar
1

posted by rachel

Mar 06, 2007 5:40PM

unilever also tests on animals, so they can shove it big time

avatar
2

posted by Arcadia

Mar 06, 2007 10:16PM

this post is genius. kudos!

avatar
3

posted by modelingnews

Mar 07, 2007 2:38AM

Over the decades, commercials for beauty soaps only featured drop-dead gorgeous girls. Seeing real-looking women endorsing a beauty soap is quite refreshing, so let's leave Dove be. It's just a marketing ploy. They'll be eventually reverting to gorgeous models anyway.

avatar
4

posted by casey

Mar 07, 2007 3:47AM

Who wants to buy reality? Gross.

I don't want to see giant bilboards with fat girls on them. So shoot me. Go back to the models. That's what they're there for anyway. Gosh.

avatar
5

posted by stonedog38

Mar 07, 2007 3:54AM

you can take your toothpick models, i'll take the dove girls, to me they are hot!

avatar
6

posted by MH

Mar 07, 2007 9:45AM

I mean, it's not like these girls break any boundaries of attractiveness aside from their size. Dove is still tacitly saying that while its okay for you have have size-14 thighs, you damn well better keep them firm and young-looking by using their lotion. I mean, nice work Photoshopping out all the cellulite; real acceptance would, you know, accept that sort of thing.

avatar
7

posted by Kimberly

Mar 07, 2007 10:51AM

This ad is definitely generating a lot of publicity, so at least it's a success on that front.

I read some good, informed analysis of it on Media 3.0, by Shelly Palmer. He wrote an essay called "Taking UGC Too Literally," and thinks it's a poor example of "user generated content" -- low quality, not too "different."

Overall though, I like the campaign.

- Kimberly

avatar
8

posted by Roberto

Mar 07, 2007 12:28PM

Three BIG cheers for Dove. It's time we stopped fostering anorexia in women, young and old.
You wanna fantasize, go find a porn site. REAL women are attractive and intriguing. If they weren't, there'd be one hell of alot less marital unions on this planet.

avatar
9

posted by screw dove

Mar 07, 2007 1:42PM

the people who are cheering these stupid "real ads" don't see the larger picture. they should show the dove soap being put in rabbit's eyes.

these overweight models are also highly airbrushed, therefore still not "real."

what a frigging joke.

avatar
10

posted by linus bern

Mar 07, 2007 11:42PM

I don't have any firm stance on the objectification of women in advertising, but those big women are the sexiest people I've ever seen on a billboard. I almost fell down the subway stairs looking at them.

avatar
11

posted by guest

Mar 08, 2007 8:54AM

I want soap, not a campaign.

avatar
12

posted by Tasha

Jul 14, 2007 3:29PM

I think it’s great that we get to see real women in real sizes; I could care less about the company that supports Dove. So many different companies out there are doing the wrong thing for example cigarette companies....lets boycott them
again congrats to these women!

Post Your Comment