Because she managed not to get thrown into a pool by 50 Cent, Dionne won the Keds challenge on Top Model, and chose fellow competitors Jaslene and Whitney to shoot the Keds campaign with her.

The ad is now running in Seventeen, and we’ve scanned it for you so that we could hold our own little judging panel.

If you look really hard, you can make out Jaslene in the bottom right corner. Squint even harder and the blur behind her becomes Whitney. As for Dionne, whose photo is front and center, we just think this shot proves she’s not the winner. She looks really uncomfortable on camera, especially considering how she’s supposed to be “casually” lounging poolside in LA. This doesn’t bode well for a Cover Girl.

And speaking of LA, is there some kind of rule that every girl in town has to own a Primp hoodie/ thermal/ sweatpant? Tyra seems to think so… maybe her friend Nicole Richie gave her a hand-me-down.