Petrea, 28, shoe guru
Got Her: walking her puppy on Second Avenue.
Stalked Her: Because Madonna hasn’t looked this sweet since 1985!
Shot Her: After following her for three blocks, we realized her outfit was as addictive as Starburst candies, and colored the same way. It was too good not to capture.

She Says: “My dress is from Urban Outfitters. My husband bought it for me while we were getting divorced because he wanted me to look nice in court! Then he complained because he wasn’t wearing a tie… My jacket is from the Salvation Army in Palm Beach – my ex-husband’s mother lived there, so I used to go visit with him. And I’ve always been into scarves – Madonna from Desperately Seeking Susan has been my style icon for like my whole life! And my company makes these boots – I wear them everywhere. People stop me a lot to ask about them. They’re stars.”
We Say: It’s not the boots, babe. It’s you.