Shopping

Stripe Three, You’re Out

oatmeal cookies.jpg
We were obsessed with the J. Crew striped coat at left - it was too expensive (over $300), but still amazing. The swing, the sleeves, the stripes - we were into it. And you must have been too, because now it’s sold out.

But yesterday, we discovered it’s very available at Zara. The coat’s the same shape, length, and colors as J. Crew’s, but boasts a single-button collar instead of the double-breasted front.

Zara’s is cheaper by about $100, relatively new to stores. Meanwhile, J. Crew’s has been in their catalogue since August, and we wonder if this is the next knockoff frontier, when a mass brand pulls from another one that’s sold out of its cult item.

Meanwhile, the coat’s closest runway origin seems to be Gareth Pugh’s signature striped jacket from Fall ‘07… but without the plastic.

—BRITT ABOUTALEB

Comments

avatar
1

posted by guest

Oct 18, 2007 3:21PM

the zara one looks like the prison outfits from o brother where art thou?

avatar
2

posted by guest

Oct 18, 2007 3:30PM

the zara one looks like the prison outfits from o brother where art thou?

avatar
3

posted by nycmode

Oct 18, 2007 4:43PM

I have that coat from Zara, but it has dark grey and black stripes. It was $189 in August and I bought it after I remembered seeing Rachel Bilson on Style.com in January in this Opening Ceremony Coat. The Zara coat is almost an exact replica- except over $300 cheaper!

http://www.style.com:80/peopleparties/parties/slideshow/011207COCO/?iphoto=24

avatar
4

posted by Pink Tartan

Oct 18, 2007 5:16PM

The J.Crew coat is great. I can see why it sold out.
The Zara one...not so much. There's no shape to it and looks like an old blanket.

avatar
5

posted by brendastarlet

Oct 18, 2007 6:51PM

Wear it quickly. This is going to become the buffalo plaid coat of 2007.

avatar
6

posted by Nia

Oct 18, 2007 7:16PM

Proenza for Target already did a double breasted swing coat with stripes last year, which I still absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE. Just not chunky stripes and from the looks of these not as warm. The Rachel Bilson one is really cute though. I like the dark gray better than yellow. the PS coat is on ebay right now for cheap $30, hurry quick, it's great. Keep up the good work ladies. More Girls Gone Styled please.

avatar
7

posted by Cynthia

Oct 18, 2007 11:36PM

That's NASTY!!

avatar
8

posted by J

Oct 18, 2007 11:38PM

not sure about the zara one... i've been eyeing it weekly in the montreal store since september... still too much for a coat that will most likely fall apart.

avatar
9

posted by Islamic Clothing | Muslim Fashion Magazine

Oct 21, 2007 4:28PM

I think the Zara one looks a bit strange and the Runway version is awful!

In terms of Zara knocking off J. Crew: at least if they did it, they gave J. Crew the chance to sell out first. This way, Zara isn't stealing from J. Crew's revenues.

Post Your Comment