News

Cruella Prevails?

Cruella.gif We’re not comfortable wearing fur, or even faux fur, but we also really dislike (perhaps even despise) the immature and ultimately ineffective tactics at Peta.


After realizing that dumping red paint on people is both grounds for a lawsuit and a violation of their own supposed belief that all living things (including people) deserve respect, they’ve moved onto a new tactic:

Dressing up their members like slutty, tacky PETA “cops.”

An interview with Ingrid Newkirk – PETA’s president and co-founder in today’s New York Observer explains the rationale behind their thongs.

“You may feel more comfortable just arguing things intellectually. But that isn’t the way society is now; it’s all Paris Hilton and Britney Spears and ‘Show us your tits,’” Ms. Newkirk said.”

Newkirk also points out that young and emerging designers hardly ever use fur. She blames the persistence of fur on older designers stuck in their ways and shock-tactic aficionados:

“I think the old fogy designers like Karl Lagerfeld and so on, and the desperate designers like Alexander McQueen who want to be bad boys—Jean Paul Gaultier—they really want to be like, ‘Look at me, look at me! Aren’t I just shameless?’

Weirdly, we think what’s really shameless is exploiting your female members for their boobs intead of their brains, which could certainly be used to passionately but respectfully explain why using fur is wrong.

Meanwhile, it seems like PETA’s on the losing end of the industry, again:

Today, Oscar de la Renta announced a new licensing deal to produce a line of fur coats for his Fall and Winter collections.

—ALISON COOL

Comments

1

posted by Bobby

Nov 19, 2007 12:34PM

it's a popular opinion to despise PETA, but i really like them. i know i'm in the minority for saying that, and aside for growing up in a really animal-rights household (yes you read correctly), i like PETA simply because they are crazy. they seem like the first and only surviving totally media-oriented and media-savvy activist group in america, and for that i find them fascinating. --B

avatar
2

posted by guest

Nov 19, 2007 12:57PM

Throwing pies and paint...that's cute. How obnoxious! By the way, what about leather? They don't seem to hurl anything at people wearing that...

avatar
3

posted by guest

Nov 19, 2007 12:58PM

I agree witht the above poster. Though I don't contribute financially to their campaign, I check the PETA website regulalrly and am part of their mailing list. They are the most comprehensive resource for living a cruelty-free life out there. I don't think they are losing any industry war, as more and more companies are being added to the no-test list at an accelerating rate, with many more companies working towards it.

As far as being crazy, check out some of the tactics of some of the more hardcore groups, such as the ALF, before attacking PETA.

4

posted by catsnphilosophy

Nov 19, 2007 1:29PM

What's crazier: Wearing fur and/or raising and killing cute animals for fur only purposes, or throwing some paint or food on fur wearers? PETA may have bizarre tactics, but they are pretty effective. And let's see, if we are going to argue morality, in my opinion, PETA is morally superior to the fur industry and designers who perpetuate it.

5

posted by arcane

Nov 19, 2007 2:20PM

I have never understood the whole crazy side of PETA. Spray-painting a fur coat makes you look like a crazed idiot as opposed to a passionate activist. I have a hard time believing that spray painting garments change ones mind about wearing fur. I personally don't use fur in my designs (just not my thing), so I don't personally run the rist of having months of work ruined; but I'm sure there are other methods that don't follow the lines of vandalism that can actually educate people about animal cruelty, as opposed to making it a media event.

avatar
6

posted by chartreusegirl

Nov 19, 2007 2:38PM

I'm with arcane on this one -- PETA'S methods totally overshadow their message. I understand the instinct to do wild things to get into the papers, but the result has been that a lot of people out there now dismiss animal activists as crazy and extremist. Imagine how many more people would listen to PETA's points if they weren't so turned off by their antics.

7

posted by Jacqueminette

Nov 19, 2007 3:12PM

Concur with the general criticisms above, as well as with guest at 12:57. While I'm sure that the people at PETA have veganism at heart, what about the rest of us? Wearing a jacket made of lamb or calf leather doesn't get much attention, but a mink coat of the same length would garner a lot of dirty looks (not to mention a few hostile comments) here in the Bay Area.

I once saw a PETA demonstration where women dressed only in [fake?] fur coats were collared and drinking out of toilet bowls or being led on leashes. On the steps of a state capitol. A true BDSM fantasy brought to life.

avatar
8

posted by guest

Nov 19, 2007 4:08PM

it amazes me that people get behind groups like PETA who want to educate the world about cruelty to animals..yet the same people have no problem with treating other humans in a cruel manner..priorities have to be re-examined.

avatar
9

posted by guest

Nov 19, 2007 6:55PM

anyone who bashes peta is not a true animal lover.

10

posted by hannah

Nov 19, 2007 7:51PM

I agree with what's generally being said (except for the guest @ 6:55...). I'm against wearing fur coats, but because of PETA's tactics I'm really turned off by them. Maybe people wouldn't pay so much attention otherwise, but really, PETA... girls in skanky "cop" costumes?

P.S. Never call Karl Lagerfield an "old fogy." Even if he does use fur.

avatar
11

posted by guest

Nov 20, 2007 2:19AM

They've lost this battle....this has been ineffective. If anything, it's made those who can afford fur buy more of it and rarer stuff.

They, just like the anti abortion people, have created alot of noise among the middle classes, but little else.

avatar
12

posted by guest

Nov 20, 2007 3:27AM

PETAs tactics do work, they worked on me. I have been a vegan now for 3 years all because of one horrible video I watched on their website.

The thing about passionate people is they do crazy things!! They are trying to save the live of tons of innocent animals, its not surprising to me at some of the things they resort to!

avatar
13

posted by guest

Nov 20, 2007 10:22AM

PETA members are like anti-abortionists? Oh please. I say, if you want to kill an animal yourself, eat it and wear it, then go ahead. Otherwise keep your ignorant mouth shut.

avatar
14

posted by guest

Nov 20, 2007 10:23AM

I am tired of people who complain about Peta. You are forgetting the reason that they resort to extreme tactics to get your attention. It is for the animals!

Tell me, what do you all do that helps others in a huge way?

Complain and bitch all you want, but buying a $300 "green" dress isn't enough.

avatar
15

posted by guest

Nov 20, 2007 10:34AM

If it wasn't for PETA, there wouldn't be an awareness level on animal cruelty issues. Yes, they're over the top and ineffective sometimes, sometimes even silly and irrelevant, but so what? No person or organization is perfect. At least they care enough to do something. You can support some of their initiatives and disagree with others. That's the beauty of it.

And to the comment on cruelty to humans: why does it have to be mutually exlusive?

Post Your Comment