Would You Wear

Would You Wear A Political Statement?

Che Guevara shirt.jpgThe idea of the fashion statement is not exactly new, but sometimes it’s taken more literally.


When we were younger, we thought wearing Converse and band tees to school made us fundamentally different from those who wore Lacoste. In college, Ché Guevara t-shirts were as common as pants. And now, it seems like everybody is either wearing an actual keffiyah, or at least some take on it, brought to us largely by the Balenciaga runway.

We think it’s kind of admirable if someone believes in something so deeply that they’re willing to literally hang it off of themselves. At the same time, when something becomes stylish it tends to lose its overt political meaning, to the point where many people wearing the trend don’t even know it has political connotations.

Maybe the classic Che Guevara shirt would be the best example of this, its message having been lost to irony and Urban Outfitters. And yet, when Marc Jacobs made those “John Kerry Is a Rock Star” tees during the last election, they completely sold out.

Would you wear a political statement? Or are your beliefs best left to your ballots?

Comments

avatar
1

posted by guest

Dec 06, 2007 12:44PM

Living in Kuwait, I know/see many girls, both Arabs and expats, wearing keffiyahs as scarves. For the most part, we wear the red and white ones that are the colors of the ethnic Saudis and Kuwaitis in the area (I'm from the states for the record). I can understand how this might be misconstrued as a political thing but unless you're deliberately wearing the black and white of the PLO, it's really just a cultural symbol.

That being said, all over Europe, those street-side carts sell randomly colored ones that I guess are simply fashion statements, while at least the Saudi ones are authentic....

2

posted by misscynthiabell

Dec 06, 2007 12:49PM

Che Guevara shirts are completely ridiculous. Why wear a shirt with the face of a communist plastered on it? When those shirts were all the rage a few years back I bought one that had Che's face on it and underneath it said,"Communism killed 1,000,000 people and all I got was this stupid t-shirt."

avatar
3

posted by guest

Dec 06, 2007 12:50PM

I would and I do. There will always be clueless people who choose something for cool or aesthetic factors who are ignorant of or apathetic about the real meaning. But heck, those people also sometimes vote and I do that too. So I'm not about to let them keep me from expressing myself.

4

posted by Kate

Dec 06, 2007 1:02PM

Soviet communism killed far more than a million people; Che eschewed Soviet communism. Granted, his methods were questionable. All the same, if he'd had a proper burial, he'd be rolling over in his grave re: the vapid ubiquity of his image.

I think you have to be very careful when it comes to cultural appropriation, and err on the side of good judgement. For example, my fiance is from Iran and would flip if he saw me casually don a keffiyah, due to the associations it has for him. Apparently it's not an issue for others. And remember the controversy a few years ago over the Chanel frock that incorporated verses of the Q'uran into the design? That was not cool.

That said, I would not hesitate to wear my own heartfelt political opinions on my sleeve, as it were.

avatar
5

posted by guest

Dec 06, 2007 1:16PM

This entry reminded me of that time Cameron Diaz offended the people of Peru when she showed up wearing that Mao Zedong messenger bag.

6

posted by Laia

Dec 06, 2007 1:37PM

As long as you are knowledgeable about the item/graphic/whatever you are wearing, then I think it's perfectly fine.

7

posted by Shanna

Dec 06, 2007 2:05PM

I agree with Laia. My friend wore some stupid shirt the other day that said "Friends don't let friends vote democrat." But when I started talking to her about politics, she got annoyed. If you choose to wear a political statement, I think you should be prepared to defend it and accept any criticisms that come along with it.

8

posted by elle

Dec 06, 2007 2:39PM

agreeing with shanna.
if you wear something but can't discuss it, then you'll look like an idiot.

avatar
9

posted by guest

Dec 06, 2007 2:42PM

Just bought a t-shirt at Urban Outfitters that said "Obama for your mama"....guilty

10

posted by arcane

Dec 06, 2007 2:58PM

For me its always a matter of 'can you defend your position?' as opposed to 'will you defend your position?'.

I don't think you have to defend anything. For me its more internal. If I wear a political statement, and I know what it means to me and understand what its about, then thats enough. I discovered that most people don't want you to defend your beliefs to prove you know what your talking about, but just because they don't agree with you and they want to be argumentative. Why waste your time on people who aren't really relevant to your life?

avatar
11

posted by guest

Dec 06, 2007 3:13PM

I think that people who wear these type of political shirts-especially che ones- are those who feel empty in their lives and want to appear to be rebellious or political, why go to political rallies or actually do something when you can simply wear a hip t-shirt?

12

posted by Shanna

Dec 06, 2007 3:38PM

I see where you’re coming from and I think that in certain circumstances, that can be true. But I think that most (if not all) political statements are going to offend SOMEBODY. For example, wearing a Nazi Swastika would offend most people. Wearing an anti-Bush shirt would offend some people. I think if you choose to wear something controversial knowing people are going to be offended by it, you’d better be prepared to defend your position and discuss it.

13

posted by adopt a shelter pet

Dec 06, 2007 4:36PM

i tend to do more of raising awareness types of things...like my name, for instance ;D

14

posted by sam alex

Dec 06, 2007 11:24PM

I have a tee that I made. It's my favorite. It says

READ
MORE

and I think that's as close as I'll get to controversy.

avatar
15

posted by guest

Dec 07, 2007 11:48AM

I wore the "Al, Save Us!" (al gore) T-shirt by MJ all summer, I even ran into MJ while wearing it! Too bad Al isn't running for president again. I'm holding out for a MJ Kucinich or Sean Penn T now.

avatar
16

posted by guest

Dec 07, 2007 11:41PM

as a few people have mentioned, I think it's perfectly fine for people to wear political statements as long as they're informed about them.
i really don't feel like they have an obligation to make any explanation or defense, though; their political stances are none of my business and they mightn't be as articulate as to be able to explain their views accurately enough (a big issue in my school, which is international and is situated in India).
i often wear keffiyehs which a lot of Danes did in the 70's and still do, as a sign of support for Yasser Arafat and the palestinians.
but nobody has the right to demand an explanation from me, for one of my personal choices - i think it's a bit like stopping a random tourist in the street and DEMANDING to know why s/he's wearing Crocs!

avatar
17

posted by guest

Dec 08, 2007 12:31AM

I just find it terribly ironic how THE anti-capitalism figure that is Che Guevara has turned into a massive product OF capitalism.

avatar
18

posted by guest

Dec 10, 2007 10:40PM

What WAS the message that people who wore Che t-shirts tried to convey? That they admire mass murderers I guess. Might as well have worn Jeff Dahmer or Hitler t's.

Post Your Comment