WHICH oldie-but-goodie model's Vogue shoot was scrapped because an editor found that she was "getting thick." (Editor's Note: She is not thick.) The shoot would have involved two other more of-the-minute models, too...
posted by guest
Apr 04, 2008 4:22PM
Oldie? Hint, please. 90s supermodel or more recent sorta supermodel?
posted by sarahchivonne
Apr 04, 2008 4:45PM
Isn't that quote from The Devil Wears Prada? Gisele was the main model cast, but i can't imagine her being thick, esp with her recent cover with lebron.
posted by guest
Apr 04, 2008 5:06PM
gemma, hilary or doutzen.....three girls that are "thick" compared to when they were new. But they just had doutzen in the last issue.
posted by adoreaudrey
Apr 04, 2008 6:15PM
Claudia Schiffer is my guess, because of her Chanel campaign. She is definately not "thick" though!
posted by lee o
Apr 04, 2008 7:13PM
Im gonna say Gemma.
I thought these two posts about her were kinda funny.
http://www.bryanboy.com/bryanboy_le_superstar_fab/2007/10/guess-chanels-p.html
http://www.bryanboy.com/bryanboy_le_superstar_fab/2008/01/gemma-wards-fac.html
posted by Katie
Apr 04, 2008 9:18PM
I wouldn't consider Gemma, Hilary or Doutzen to be "Oldies". I am thinking it must be someone older than that, but I don't know who.
posted by Kara
Apr 04, 2008 9:59PM
I really hope it wasn't Gemma....I'd guess she could be an "oldie" by now...
posted by guest
Apr 05, 2008 11:37AM
i think it's coco. am i the only one who thinks she has put on a tiny weeny teensy bit of weight? she still looks healthy and i love her but i think she's a little fleshy.
posted by guest
Apr 05, 2008 3:39PM
To me an "oldie" a Linda, Kate, Naomi... I"m going with Linda E. She's gorgeous still but not as tiny as the models today...
posted by trentnyc
Apr 06, 2008 8:18AM
saying that she actually is not thick rules out coco (you know it's true). hilary's face is more what is sought than her body. doutzen is known for her figure. i will scream if it's kate.
posted by Cortege
Apr 06, 2008 1:01PM
Kate? pas possible... she looks unbelievable in the current issue of Paris Vogue.
Linda?
posted by guest
Apr 06, 2008 3:56PM
I heard from several people that Gemma is supposedly getting thick, but whatever!!!
posted by Cortege
Apr 07, 2008 6:09AM
Funnily enough, Style.com has the Video of the actual Chanel show from which the photograph showing Gemma's body appeared. She looks... normal in the video. That means normal, not someone with sticks for legs. She looks like a very very very beautiful woman.
posted by guest
Apr 07, 2008 11:15AM
I am 99.9% sure that photo of Gemma is PhotoShopped. If you look at the rest of the photos from that Chanel show at, say, Style.com, she looks fine -- not bumpy or lumpy at all.
posted by guest
Apr 07, 2008 8:01PM
Gemma has put on quite a bit of weight lately, but I doubt she could be referred to as an "Oldie". Vogue has supported Linda in the past when she was beyond her prime and bigger than she'd ever been. I think it's her, she's been doing some editorials lately, and she is even bigger, but I would be very discouraged if they didn;t work around her bigger frame. They did give her a cover when she was doing pretty much nothing with her career...but didn't Linda just give birth like a year or so ago? Other oldies, Kate Moss and Claudia Schiffer and Naomi Campbell and dare I say it, Angela Lindvall are still very thin and fit. Even Stephanie Seymour is sitll pretty small, but did she ever do Vogue? Maybe it was Paulina Porizkova...Anyway, I doubt Hilary or Coco or Gemma or Doutzen are "oldies but goodies," by that same token Daria and Gisele would be ancient...
posted by guest
Apr 07, 2008 11:54PM
ok, you know what? the "how much is this costing me" bit is an obvious allusion to Linda Evangelista's "i don't get out of bed for less than 10,000 dollars" bit, so it has to be her...
posted by guest
Apr 08, 2008 3:20AM
My guess would be Linda. A recent candid pic showed her with a much fuller face. And yes, Stephanie did a lot of Vogue work, with at least 5 covers and editorial, both pre and post GN'R.
posted by guest
Apr 08, 2008 5:30AM
yeah, that photo of Gemma is totally photoshopped... but anyway, I know this si going back a little bit, at Heath Ledger's funeral, she looked like a normal person, not like a model (in terms of thinness). yay for Gemma!!!!! PS Linda has totally put on weight. also, no way is it sasha. i mean, hello! also, obviously it's not Kate. she will never be thick.
posted by guest
Apr 29, 2008 11:33PM
To me Gemma does not fit the definition of thick at all. She looks great.
posted by Lindsaysue12
Apr 04, 2008 4:00PM
She's not an "oldie"...but the only one I can think of is Hilary Rhoda.