3
posted by adristar
Apr 07, 2008 3:51PM
well that's not exactly the palestinian scarf.... and it's already on mall kids! has been for at least a year! i live in ontario, and i've seen ones made with sparkly gold threading, and in purple and pink - which is far more ridiculous.
and - do kids/people in general know where their clothes are coming from at all? whether it's a ripoff from another designer's collection, or from a sweatshop, or if it's representative of a political struggle.
8
posted by hipstersdontlie
Apr 07, 2008 4:03PM
Yeah come on, it's not like a Nazi symbol on a jacket or something.
9
posted by andremichael
Apr 07, 2008 4:06PM
they also sell these on arbitrary street corners in NYC. i mean.. at this point, why not, abercrombie? lol.
11
posted by anna_muffin
Apr 07, 2008 4:27PM
Well, I'm from Europe and it's true that people have been wearing these scarves for some time now...and a lot of people, too...and of course, everyone should be allowed to wear whatever they want...but people wearing these scarves definitely lose points in my eyes.
12
posted by poseur
Apr 07, 2008 4:39PM
while this one looks more like a tablecloth, the original: i am sick of it, to be honest-and I am middle eastern, I've seen it many times but now everywhere is saturated with it! I started counting how many of them I see throughout the day. Is this the only scarf that could be described "ethnic"? NO! There are tons of options, and people keep buying it over and over again.
13
posted by guest
Apr 07, 2008 4:42PM
I don't see the shemagh as a political statement or anything. Obviously it's like fairly synonymous with a certain part of the world, but it's standard issue for every armed force in the world for desert combat. Keeps out sand and sun etc.
It's functional.
heh.
16
posted by guest
Apr 07, 2008 4:49PM
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keffiyeh#Symbol_of_Palestinian_solidarity.3F
20
posted by guest
Apr 07, 2008 5:02PM
i would make snid comments to the manager of urban outfitters when they started carrying them back in 2006, like "Oh, i guess you are all for palestine then?" i wish people where more socially conscious but it doesn't even matter now because it is so saturated in the market.
21
posted by ARitchNYC
Apr 07, 2008 5:11PM
I also agree with dHOMMEc. It is only a matter of time before these scarfs go through the lower department store ranks (yes, lower than where they are now). I suppose the process takes time, but eventually this cliche, not-so-chic item will become a thing of the past.
23
posted by Lindsaysue12
Apr 07, 2008 5:34PM
psssh I could care less if a scarf is a trend or not. If its cold outside, which it typically is here in MN, I'll wear a scarf.
27
posted by guest
Apr 07, 2008 6:51PM
Speaking of people not knowing the origins of things...
It's "whoa." W-H-O-A. It's in the dictionary and everything! It's what one says to a horse to make it stop. It was made popular as a phrase to express general amazement or wonder in the 80s and 90s mainly by Keanu Reeves (see Bill & Ted's) and Joey Lawrence (see Blossom).
I deeply appreciate your reviving this most awesome word, but PLEASE -- spell it right already!
32
posted by cassie
Apr 07, 2008 11:09PM
a few weeks ago i (rather ignorantly) purchased this keffiyeh-esque scarf from isabel marant...does anyone know the one i'm talking about? she had it on almost every look in her spring '08 show. i haven't worn it yet, mainly because i can't seem to be able to walk down the street here in boston without seeing some version of it. however i always like to wear a scarf and finding one in a light weight fabric was so appealing...if anyone knows the one i'm talking about will they let me know their opinion, is this particular one too trendy?!
34
posted by guest
Apr 08, 2008 12:12AM
Okay I hate how mainstream this is getting because now I feel trendy having one. I didn't even know this was starting to become a trend but I remember as a kid back in the 90's the middle eastern vendors used to sell these on the streets in Brooklyn, so when I found one a year ago I bought it out of nostalgia...
35
posted by guest
Apr 08, 2008 2:18AM
The keffiyeh is part of the general Israeli-Arab controversy, supporters of the Palestinian cause see the keffiyeh as a symbol of a just cause, while some others see the keffiyeh as representing anti-Seimitism, terrorism, or the intention to eliminate the Jewish State. In 2007, the American clothing store chain, Urban Outfitters, stopped selling keffiyehs because of fear that selling them might be seen “to imply any sympathy for or support of terrorists or terrorism.” [5] The Independent calls the keffiyeh a “disturbing… symbol of Islamic militancy” [6] Columnist Carolyn P. Glick equates the Palestinian keffiyeh with the fascist wearing of brown shirts. [7] A spokesman for Spain’s Popular Party accused Prime Minister Zapatero of "anti-Semitism, anti-Zionism and Israelophobia," after he was photographed wearing a keffiyeh. [8]
#5 ^ http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1167467767600&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FPrinter
#6 ^ WITHOUT “BOUNDARY: 17 WAYS OF LOOKING,” The Independent (London, England) April 28, 2006 , by Rhoda Koenig
#7 ^ No Tolerance for Genocide, By Carolyn P. Glick, Jerusalem Post, August 2, 2002
#8 ^ http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/07/20/news/spain.php
41
posted by Cortege
Apr 08, 2008 7:36AM
I thought this style was over! Some people have said that this isn't exactly a 'middle eastern' style one, and that is true.
A scarf is a scarf. I find the style (size wise) and fabric of these scarves pretty comfortable. I have friends who bought theirs in the respective countries when they were traveling there: they're not gonna stop wearing them because they came into 'fashion'.
You can usually tell who wears these as a 'trend' , and who wears them because they are a useful part of their wardrobe. As with most things.
Isabel Marant did the keffiyeh as well.
Abercrombie's is a pretty (and overpriced, probably) tablecloth. Are they trying to be funny? As in.. parody?
42
posted by oui_oui
Apr 08, 2008 7:43AM
:|
Wow. Okay, first of all, that is NOT a Keffiyeh. This is a totally different pattern. I should know, I AM and currently LIVE in the Mid-East. So to all you I-was-over-it-before-it-started know-it-alls, get your patterns straight.
And it is not so controversial. It is worn in the Gulf as well, has been for many, many years. It IS a symbol of solidarity, but it is also just part of the traditional ensemble worn by Arab men.
and FYI, Balenciaga did not invent the whole Keffiyeh-scarf look. Independent Arab designers across the Middle East have used the pattern in many of their designs, especially in scarves.
43
posted by HeatherChandler
Apr 08, 2008 10:41AM
I got one as a gift waaay back in 1991. Didn't wear it then and I won't wear it now.
44
posted by Aaron Christopher
Apr 08, 2008 11:33AM
I work there. I think they're cute. The forms have them wearing the scarves with tank tops and jeans. Yeah, the styles been around for a while but the entire point of fashion and style is to wear what you want and make it look good. So if you can wear and work it, I say go for it!
48
posted by guest
Apr 08, 2008 6:07PM
The Hipsters/Scenesters/Emo kids definitely have been wearing this for a while.
I can credit this to many bands, such as Cobra Starship, namely the lead singer, Gabe Saporta, that have been wearing these scarves. The controversy is clear about them, but in reality, isn't it just another fashion fad?
52
posted by guest
Jun 22, 2008 9:31AM
honestly to me.
people are using these scarves for fashion statements. i am guilty of this. but i am a devot catholic. i don't go around rambling to people who wear roasries (a religious object and sacred tool in my eyes) as a fashion statment.
do some research on shemaghs and rosaries.
posted by la petite fashionista
Apr 07, 2008 3:42PM
wow! does abercrombie not understand how controversial this scarf is? i'm guesssing not..