posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 12:22PM

I love Scott to death, Hopefully we'll see him in the adds?!
So excited!

posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 12:29PM

amazing!

posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 12:57PM

I used to love Scott before the whole Makeover Fiasco. I realize he's explained his motivations exhaustively, but sadly I can't seem to muster the same joy anymore regardless. He just seems so full of himself to me now.

posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 2:43PM

guest 1257--

what's the makeover fiasco?

posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 2:47PM

guest 1257--

what's the makeover fiasco?

posted by purly

Apr 24, 2008 3:39PM

I have a mad crush on that man.

posted by fashionursta

Apr 24, 2008 4:01PM

I agree with guest @12:57 he does seem a little full of himself now. I can't really put it into words. But he does take great pictures, well composed, etc. I have never met him on the street in nyc (I live here too), and have always wondered if he would find my daily persona worth snapping. It is so interesting how the internet is becoming the great equalizer among us.

posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 4:36PM

Fall 2008, not 2009

posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 6:14PM

The makeover post is April 11 at his site, so it's pretty easy to find...best to read his words and the posters reactions for yourself.

This kind of explains why he recommended Gap for his makeover girl.

posted by guest

Apr 24, 2008 9:11PM

is it really that serious that he wanted to make someone over? i love him and if he want make someone over, i say YAY. i am excited to see the results.

posted by disneyrollergirl

Apr 25, 2008 4:31AM

I kind of want to defend him because although I felt a bit 'oh dear' about the makeover idea, I can't say I think he's got too full of himself. All we know of him is what we read on his site, few of us have met him. Things can be misconstrued on blogs, in emails and in text messages. The tone gets lost, sarcasm and irony can be missed. So I prefer to give him the benefit of the doubt. He's probably dreading putting up the results of the makeover for fear of an even bigger backlash than the announcement.

PS, love that b/w pic of him...

posted by RayBay

Apr 25, 2008 11:21AM

He's extremely talented. Too bad about that personality of his.

The Times of India story which he posted on is a good example. He told a reporter he paid a certain -- exorbitant for Indians, cheap for westerners-- amount for a bottle of essential oil, and got super pissed at her when she changed his words so that it made him look like he wasn't taken advantage of quite as badly. Stupid move on the reporter's part, but Sart displayed a bullheaded, touristy ignorance as to why she changed it.....He couldn't understand that she was actually trying to protect his image.

Also, his tendency to only shoot the very thin, often at angles that make them look thinner still (in particular, a certain whimsical asian woman comes to mind), and then act offended when people question the choice (or wonder why he never chooses to shoot the over-a-size-4 well dressed --- they do exist, folks!)

In comparison, these instances make the so called "makeover fiasco" seem like not quite as big of a deal, at least to me.

I'll still keep visiting the site, tho. One can't deny he's got a great eye for detail.