Explain

Do Fashion Shows Belong in Schools?

parish nation sweatshirt.jpgThe New York Times has a great story today on Parish Nation, a clothing label popular with hip hop artists that goes into troubled public schools and produces fashion shows.

The brand’s founder, Tony Shellman, argues that producing a fashion show teaches teamwork, responsibility, business skills, creativity, and risk taking.

Of course, it also produces consumerism, superficial judgments and solutions, and class division, or at least heightened class awareness.

When we were in college, there was a “charity fashion show.” It was a huge deal, where if you got cast as a model, you were automatically deemed one of the school’s most desirable girls, and if you weren’t somehow working on it (as a “stylist,” an art director, a publicist, a producer, whatever) you decided you hated the whole crew - even in the high school from the article, Camden High in New Jersey, only a little more than half of the students were allowed to attend the show with priority going to athletes, honor students and those with perfect attendance, arguably the kids who need the extra attention the least.

Obviously, using a Fashion Show as an opportunity for self esteem and business experience is different - but is it different enough to encourage in all schools?

Comments

avatar
1

posted by andremichael

May 21, 2008 10:47AM

actually a lot of HS in the northeast (esp schools that are arts-related) have fashion shows, fashion troupes, etc. they compete with other schools in their district & everything. it's a big deal (2 them) and like any other extracurricular [band, chorus, newspaper, etc] - it can provide a positive outlook & give kids a sense of responsibility and leadership as they put their shows 2gether, seek out designers & the like.

the downside, of course, being these kids actually thinking that they ARE real models and that what they do IS real fashion. but their experiences can peak an initial interest in the industry that can definitely grow as they do.

2

posted by leia

May 21, 2008 10:47AM

I think the difference here is that Parish Nation is going into "troubled schools" as opposed to private schools or schools with a higher graduation success rate. One of the lines I represent is "urban" and we've done similar things. I think that the fashion shows in the troubled schools are great, it's something that inspires these kids and gives them (realistic) goals and dreams. The ones I've been involved in usually invite as many kids to join in to participate as possible.

I think it's great what he's doing, and he's probably getting kids involved who would normally see learning "teamwork, responsibility, business skills, creativity, and risk taking" as nerdy or uncool, but since it's fashion, something that they are interested in, they participate.

3

posted by PJH

May 21, 2008 10:48AM

Fashion shows are a part of school life. For some reason, I always remember them existing. I remember when my elementary school decided to get uniforms, we had a uniform fashion show. I was not part of it, only the loser daughter and sons of the PTA moms. I was, however, in the senior fashion show. We modeled formal wear and I wore a black tuxedo with a gold vest and bowtie! By then I was hot and one of the popular kids.

avatar
4

posted by guest

May 21, 2008 10:52AM

"Of course, it also produces consumerism, superficial judgments and solutions, and class division, or at least heightened class awareness"

Wow, that sounds uncannily like this website!

avatar
5

posted by guest

May 21, 2008 10:54AM

Speaking as a public school teacher in Philly, who knows many people who teach at Camden High, I would argue the point that athletes, honor students, and those with perfect attendance don't need the extra attention. Those are the students who need to be encouraged as much as possible--in an environment like Camden, it's very easy to let go of your goals and ideals when everyone else around you is dropping out.

I think a Fashion Show is an excellent opportunity for students to experience the business world. Particularly since so many of my students want to get into the fashion industry because they see the glitz and glamour, but they have no idea of the hard work and sacrifice that often goes along with that.

avatar
6

posted by guest

May 21, 2008 11:32AM

I don't know, school fashion shows make me thing of the type of crap on Laguna Beach.

A fashion show COULD teach "teamwork, responsibility, business skills, creativity, and risk taking" except that's NOT what high school kids take from things like this. They learn to judge, ridicule, and practice elitism.

But I definitely comment Parish Nations efforts.

avatar
7

posted by Donald

May 21, 2008 12:17PM

My high school had a prom fashion show every year before the actual prom season started. I was obvs cast as a male model (two years) so not quite sure how it made the ugly people feel. Wouldn't they want to bask in my success?

avatar
8

posted by guest

May 21, 2008 12:35PM

Guest at 11:32 am:

While I think that is the downside to this sort of thing, I don't necessarily think they are all bad. I have personally never coordinated such an event, but I can just think of the planning and organization that has to go into it: designing or pulling the clothes, setting up auditions for the models, advertising the show, setting up a time and place, designing lighting and sets, arranging seating, possibly arranging row assignments, sending out invitations, etc. etc. etc. When you consider that a ton of kids have trouble completing their HOMEWORK on time, it's a huge responsibility if it is something they are truly doing on their own.

Andremichael:
I agree that another downside is that you get kids that legitimately think that because they've walked a few of their friends' shows, because they watch ANTM religiously, and because their friends think that they're pretty and walk well that they have a serious shot at real modeling. So long as they don't let their fantasies become delusions, I think those notions are generally harmless.

Oooh, Fashionista, could we have more posts like these?

avatar
9

posted by emilyebba

May 21, 2008 12:57PM

i'm glad that you guys are honest and commited enough to say that sometimes a fashion show isn't the best thing! in an art camp i interned at we once had the kids make clothes and they had a fashion show, but since the clothes were their creations, and it wasn't on a serious runway or anything, the kids had a lot of fun because they were proud of their creations. If they were older I think it could have been a nightmare.

10

posted by Modupe

May 21, 2008 6:43PM

Yes, making the fashion show is a bit of a popularity contest so i really don't get why i was in my school's show this year as one of the few freshman to make it.

11

posted by DAgnesCapone

Jun 17, 2008 9:25PM

I have a little trouble with this only because I'm so OCD and if it doesn't look like something a professional PR firm has put together, I would be squirming in my seat.

No way I could sit through 20 minutes of mall fashions and crepe paper streamers.

Post Your Comment