Explain

My Fashion Identity Crisis

preppy.jpgRecently, I’ve been thinking about the way I used to dress.

A few years ago, my look consisted of J.Crew oxfords, Lacoste polos, Top-Siders, seersucker and bleeding madras, and I was perfectly content. But then I came to New York, found myself surrounded by hipsters and cool kids, and had my first fashion identity crisis.

At first, it seemed just fine to go to Brooklyn in penny loafers or the LES in my funny Ralph Lauren cardigans, but as time went on, I decided my look needed to change. I can pinpoint the exact moment: a Rag & Bone sample sale, where I tried on a certain black jacket that made my friend tell me I looked like Pony Boy from The Outsiders. And just like that, it happened.

I was hooked. Suddenly, skinny pants seemed oddly apropos, and Top-Siders could infer irony, rather than preparedness for a yacht. I discovered Cheap Mondays, and down the rabbit hole I went. It was part announcing that I’d moved, part excuse to buy all new stuff, but looking back, I realize I just wanted to dress myself as the new person I knew I was becoming. (I think this may be what happens to girls, when suddenly, at fifteen, they enter hardcore eyeliner years until college.)

It wasn’t until I visited home again that my new clothes seemed like interlopers in my arch-WASP closet. I had spent most of the year trying to reconcile the two aesthetics, until I realized that all I really wanted was to climb into my chinos and be me again.

And so I did. I left my Pony Boy jacket at home, with the Marc Jacobs sweatshirt I just had to have. And now, I feel comfortable enough to say, I’m not cool, and I don’t need to be.

Guess I just needed a fashion crisis to figure it out, though I’ll save my Rag & Bone jacket forever, like baby shoes .

—BRETT KANE

Comments

avatar
1

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 2:34PM

If you don't want it, I'll take the MJ sweater...

avatar
2

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 2:46PM

Good for you Brett.
I have a friend who i pray every day will go through the same cycle you did - hes trying to dress one way when his style is totally the opposite. I just want him to get back in touch with what he feels and looks most comfortable in.
There's nothing more awkward than someone who's dying to dress one way but still forcing themselves to dress another.
much love.

avatar
3

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 2:58PM

brett, my brother is the same way, and it is actually quite on trend in a way, if you ask me. my whole family dresses not necessarily preppy, but very old collegiate (think old trovata or even tenenbaums) and I alway think we look cooler than everyone else, b/c it is natural for us. i know it's weird, but it's kind of comforting to stick to your cohesive family look...though I do thank god thom browne has the brooks bros. collection now, just for a little extra cool.

avatar
4

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 2:59PM

I'm sorry, but this post is embarrassing. Does your style really have so much to do with blending in? What's so fashionista about that?

You don't seem "comfortable" to me.

avatar
5

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 3:25PM

Brett, allow me to handle this one: #4, you're a fucking moron. This post was cute and funny and if you've never found yourself wearing something that perhaps wasn't completely your style, you're a liar. Let's just be thankful that there's one less hipster out there. And hope that the street style posts will start featuring more Chuck Bass types. Shark sweaters, sigh.

avatar
6

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 3:33PM

Few for a minute there..... I lost myself....I lost myself. conformist.

avatar
7

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 3:36PM

Top-siders could imply irony. You could infer that someone else was trying to be ironic by wearing Top-siders.

And I agree think real style really is about wearing what you feel comfortable in, and making it look good, making it look like it is really you, rather than just wearing something fashionable.

avatar
8

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 4:20PM

Really glad that someone at Fashionista thinks this. Your streetwalkers (while often very cute) are usually wearing hipster-type outfits. Nice to see a different point of view.

avatar
9

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 4:43PM


"For me, style is about not being afraid to try something new but being honest enough with yourself that even though "it" might be "fashionable", "it" might not be you."

The Sartorialist said it best, and I'm happy that you were able to see it for yourself Brett :)

avatar
10

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 4:55PM

glad you think being a wasp is an achievement in life

11

posted by sarahchivonne

Aug 28, 2008 5:19PM

^^ nasty nasty! ^^

avatar
12

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 6:47PM

I have that book.

avatar
13

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 7:01PM

I can totally relate Brett. Fashion really can have transforming effects on how one thinks and feels of oneself. So much is said about a person by what they wear and, as much as we all hate to admit it, we DO judge a book by its cover. That is why it is so important to be you when it comes to fashion and adopt a style that you are comfortable with. And to those who find this post shallow or pointless-take note! You might just need a makeover yourself!

avatar
14

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 7:25PM

I find this funny because I went through the opposite fashion identity crisis when I went away to boarding school in Connecticut after years of living in California wearing "surfer slash cowboy casual." I spent 4 years in high school trying to figure out the whole ribbon belt/Nantucket Red/ Madras/ Polos thing and I always felt ridiculous. It was amazing to come back to Cali for college and dress like me again.

avatar
15

posted by guest

Aug 28, 2008 8:46PM

No, number 5, I'm not a fucking idiot, and usually I love what these women have to say about fashion, but I cringe when I read articles about how contrived their fashion choices are.

16

posted by brett_kane

Aug 28, 2008 11:18PM

two things.

guest 3. if your family dresses like the tenenbaums, I want to meet them, and you. and I miss old trovata. :( in this case more is more.


guest 4/15. I'm not a woman. I'm barely an adult. and if you read the post, you would realize that I came to terms with not blending in.


Its like the passages from the SAT. you have to read the whole thing.

17

posted by Halie

Aug 29, 2008 12:25AM

brett, you are my favorite on fashionista :)

I think that all your posts are sweet and well-thought out and I like that you're not afraid to talk about yourself.

avatar
18

posted by guest

Aug 29, 2008 1:52AM

Hmmm...am I the only person who wears JCrew, but none of the other associated labels. Ok I have some thrift store RL, but thats it. I guess my preppy love is exclusive to JCrew (hehe especially when JCrew is on sale).

avatar
19

posted by guest

Aug 29, 2008 7:58AM

#10: glad you think being anonymously and unnecessarily bitchy on the internet is an achievement in life . . .

avatar
20

posted by fabfo

Aug 29, 2008 9:15AM

Brett, i really liked this post, because for all the "don't we have gucci for these people" and other pretentiousness that this site sometimes has, posts like this keep me coming beck cuz they remind me that you guys are real people who love fashion and aren't afraid to share that

21

posted by helene

Aug 29, 2008 11:38AM

Brett i loooove your posts!! They're always so cute and full of humour and sarcasm. And always interesting, of course. Some readers on this site definitely seem to have trouble grasping that concept.

And am i the only one who stopped in my tracks with the eyeliner phase statement?? i mean, SOOOOO true!!!!

avatar
22

posted by guest

Aug 29, 2008 12:03PM

brett is my favorite! keep up all the good work fashionista.

23

posted by ginni27

Aug 29, 2008 12:40PM

I must admit- I'm a total J.crew junkie. Yes, my east coast/Baltimore roots are not things that can be torn up by shear displacement. With that said, i find myself mixing all the new trends into a preppy reinvention.

avatar
24

posted by guest

Aug 29, 2008 1:29PM

#5- Ha, it's weird, you almost seem possessive of him or something. Anyway, you could say clothing in itself is conforming, but I do think some people can conform more then others. And, personally, I like to wear sort of strange things sometimes, but I usually save them for home or going to parties and shit, since I go to a really bad high school where people get beat up all the time and I don't really want to attract unnecessary attention to myself.
Erm, I don't know what my point is.

25

posted by valenlb

Aug 30, 2008 1:58AM

I have a serious soft spot for J Crew. Really, I love it to death.

Loved this post and your honesty! And: "Its like the passages from the SAT. you have to read the whole thing." Ah, such painful standardized testing memories, and yet what you say is so true...

26

posted by Charlotte

Aug 30, 2008 10:32AM

I can totally relate, i love the preppy park avenue/ralph lauren/j.crew style more than anything, but a part of me feels silly, because most of my friends dress like erin wasson, but in the end i don't care because i love this style, and it's just who i am.

avatar
27

posted by 2mewmew

Aug 30, 2008 11:43PM

Aw, Brett, I loved this! Fashion is totally about being yourself, so if preppy clothes are what you feel comfortable in then go ahead and wear it! And anyway, the whole "cool" hipsters look is everywhere. I think you are cool for realizing that look isn't you and that you don't have to blend in.
LOL! "SAT passage" xD

Post Your Comment