Ad History, Slideshows
Balenciaga: Fall 2000 vs Fall 2008
By Natalie Hormilla Friday, Sep 26, 2008 / 2:10 PM
Thanks to Leah’s obsessive archiving of magazines and all noteworthy ads, we’re starting a new ongoing conversation here on Fashionista, all about ad campaigns.
First up, Balenciaga. At left, we have a Fall 2000 ad, shot by Inez van Lamsweerde and Vinoodh Matadin. At right, the more familiar Fall 2008, shot by David Sims.
Of note first, obviously, is the use of a celebrity, Charlotte Gainsbourg, instead of models. With Charlotte, come connotations that inevitably affect how we think of the ad – Charlotte is sweet, down to earth, subtle, kind of crunchy. We’re supposed to be struck by her in such a stiff, alien-like pose, her seemingly inhuman shadow meant to scare the hell out of us. In focus is the armor-like severity of the dress, just before our eyes finally fall onto the shoes, accessories having become so much more of a focal point for major houses in recent seasons.
But in Fall 2000, the story was different. The models come with no baggage at all, so we can only really guess what they’re supposed to be telling us, the mystery seeming to lay somewhere between the model’s awareness of the camera, and the bizarreness of a horse on stairs he’d have trouble climbing anyway (assuming they’re ordinary house stairs).
On a side note, doesn’t that dog sweater now seem like the un-ironic predecessor of the Chanel penguin sweater?
Now, your turn.
Most Popular Stories
Comments [4]
Staff
- Executive Editor
- Leah Chernikoff
- Features & Beauty Editor
- Cheryl Wischhover
- Fashion News Editor
- Hayley Phelan
- Associate Editor
- Dhani Mau
- Editorial Assistant
- Nora Crotty
- Contributors
- Steff Yotka, Alice Pfeiffer, Ashley Jahncke, John Ortved, Chris Benz, Zandile Blay, John Jannuzzi, Sally Lyndley, Elana Fishman, Sarah Ferguson, Natalie Matthews, Misty White Sidell, Alaina Hernandez, Amanda Enowitz, Dana Kruspe, Modesta Dziautaite, Elysia Mann, Fawnia Soo Hoo, Nora Crotty, Jennifer Chan, Jihan Forbes, India-Jewel Jackson, Jo Piazza, Justine Harman, Tyler McCall
Popular Stories
Recommendations
Topics
Agyness Deyn Alexa Chung Alexander McQueen Alexander Wang Anna Wintour Balenciaga Barneys Carine Roitfeld Chanel Chloe Coco Rocha ELLE Fall 09 Fashion Trivia Fashion Week Gap Gossip Girl Gucci H&M J. Crew Jeremy Kost Kanye West Karlie Kloss Karl Lagerfeld Kate Middleton Kate Moss Lady Gaga Louis Vuitton Marc Jacobs Michelle Obama Models Net-a-Porter Prada Project Runway Rachel Zoe Stella McCartney Target Teen Vogue Television TopShop Urban Outfitters Vivienne Westwood Vogue Vogue UK WWD






The 10 Best YouTube Hair Tutorials
The 10 Best YouTube Makeup Tutorials
Fashion's Most Stylish Guys Give Mark Zuckerberg an (Almost!) Hoodie-Free Makeover for Facebook's IPO
Style and Substance: 10 Ladies Who Have Proven You Can Have Both
Penis Print Pants Exist and They Cost $150 
Very true…and if I’m not wrong the 2000 ads was the last that featured menswear.
I have a dog shirt with that exact same graphic on it but the tee shirt is yellow. I think it was in a woody allen movie too…Bought it from anthropologie. How curious.
i havent seen this new ad yet, what magazine was it featured in?
I think F/W 2004 had one page with a man in a shearling jacket, dark and shaggy hair, and a scruffy face.