Trendspotting

An Upswing in the Bad Economy?

loro piana scarf go bye bye.jpgWWD has been documenting the downfall of our economy, and all the fashion roadkill that’s gone with it. Today’s reported victim? Cashmere.

According to their research, knitwear manufacturers are producing much less cashmere for Spring because it’s probably too expensive for most people right now. They say companies are trying to put out more wallet-friendly cotton blends, and Qi Cashmere has even dropped the “Cashmere” from their brand name.

So here’s something we just realized: If people start buying less cashmere (though we admit, we love it), and more cotton-based clothes, that probably means a whole lot less dry cleaning, which means a cleaner environment (perc, the solvent typically used by dry cleaners, is considered a hazardous air contaminant by the EPA), not to mention one fewer monthly bill.

And it doesn’t stop there - If people still want to shop but want to keep the per-instance footprint on their checking account as small as possible, they’ll probably avoid expensive furs and leathers (so we guess PETA members can sleep a little sounder), too.

And who knows, maybe this will turn into more farmers planting cotton to get in on the trend, which would only make its price drop further for everyone.

But back to this economy-environment relationship - could what happens to us financially impact what we do to our environment? Guess we’ll find out - Unless of course, we get a Zoot Suit effect, in which case, prepare to see certain ladies strolling Madison in full-length mink capes.

Comments

avatar
1

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 9:25AM

Do people really still dry-clean cashmere sweaters? It's so much better for the fabric to hand-wash with a gentle detergent. The chemicals are way too harsh for cashmere.

avatar
2

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 9:38AM

good. the past few years the production of cashmere has ruined landscapes. Cashmere farmers have overloaded land with goats and they basically eat everything on the land and make it unavailable for a couple years. womp womp.

3

posted by syako

Oct 22, 2008 9:40AM

Not my cashmere! ;)

Random thought - I've read in multiple places that it's actually not good to dry clean cashmere and that you should actually hand wash it.

Anyone else hear that?

avatar
4

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 9:55AM

I just wanted to make a small comment on your remark about dry cleaning - my parents own a dry cleaning business in Michigan. There are really strict regulations about the whole deal with "perc". My parents only use machines that have excessive filters and such to help minimize any damage to the environment. Also, the environmental department in the state government makes sure to have the machines regularly tested and completely cleaned inside and out (weekly). Pretty much, I'm just saying that there is a GREAT amount of work put in by dry cleaning businesses to minimize their environmental impact :)

5

posted by elle

Oct 22, 2008 10:26AM

Hmm...an increase in cotton production might make the price go down, but I don't know if that would necessarily a be good thing for the environment. No one says that cotton growers would be raising organic crops and I doubt that cotton production would significantly increase in the U.S. should this "trend" take hold, which could mean that a bunch of developing countries would be doing it instead and possibly destroying their environment. Also Cambridge's study on fast fashion concluded that cotton used up a lot of energy, more so than vicose, since it usually went through a dryer as well as washing machine. I get that vicose isn't the same as cashmere, but considering that you're supposed to hand-wash and then hang-dry cashmere (and thus use up less energy and water to take care of it), I wonder if increased cotton consumption is actually better for the environment?

But then again, this is just an initial, half-baked thought, so take this as you will...

avatar
6

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 11:01AM

What a well written and thought inspiring post...I hope that an environmentally friendly outcome in the positive result of this negative economic donwslide

avatar
7

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 12:45PM

Actually, a fall in the price of inputs does not necessarily mean a fall in the price of a final good. You are assuming perfect competition here and a market with no externalities. Also, I, and most of the people I know, hand wash our cashmere. Furthermore, at least here in Boulder, Colorado, there are "green" dry cleaners available. I thought this post was really uninformed.

avatar
8

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 1:27PM

the most environmentally friendly silver lining of all would just be reduced consumption! when people can't afford as much stuff life gets a little greener for all:)

9

posted by kenya

Oct 22, 2008 2:41PM

Consumption has already decreased with gasoline demand dropping 4.3% yr on yr. If this trend continues, it would be the first annual drop since 1991. Also, less new trucks being sold and less flights being taken are resulting in lessened demand for other fuel based products. Of course consuming less fuel is better for the environment but consumption is mainly down because people have lost their jobs or have less disposable income.

The real question is, if the slumping economy prolongs or continues to worsen, will people take more drastic steps to limit consumption and will this change be permanent or will consumers relapse once the economy strengthens? And i'm not taking about a few instances in Boise, ID or Knoxville, TN i'm talking about a broad societal shift in consumer habits.

One last point, most green type goods or services cost more and will probably see their demand wane as consumers have less disposable income. Also, companies investment in green technology will decrease with less lending by banks and less demand by consumers.

avatar
10

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 3:38PM

Strange to think so but fur manufacturing is actually a lot greener (by quite a bit) than most textile processing.

avatar
11

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 5:11PM

i get all my cashmere dry cleaned. can someone recommend one of these gentle cleansers you're supposed to use for hand washing? thanks!

avatar
12

posted by guest

Oct 22, 2008 7:32PM

the best way to wash cashmere is by hand in very cold water using a detergent meant for delicates (I use Woolite - don't know if you have that in the US.) Wring it out gently and dry flat on a towel or something. It makes your cashmere smell much nicer than that chemical dry cleaning smell too..

13

posted by Halie

Oct 22, 2008 10:11PM

OR you could only buy domestically made clothes. why?

for the us, there's more regulation on how much pollution factories put out

it takes less energy to ship the clothes than from overseas

it helps your economy (heaven knows we need it)!!!

avatar
14

posted by guest

Oct 23, 2008 11:43AM

Why not use Google before writing a column? Then it would have been a more well-informed post, than just a random... "you know I have been thinking".

In that case the post would have focused on the issue of soil erosion guest #2 brought up instead of a vague dry cleaning is kind of bad for the environment non sequitur. Not that I want to discourage random thoughts, only that they can easily be beefed up by some actual information.

avatar
15

posted by guest

Oct 23, 2008 8:56PM

since we care about details in fashion, I think you mean "one less monthly bill" or "one monthly bill fewer"

16

posted by purly

Oct 25, 2008 10:00AM

Who makes cashmere for spring anyhow?

Post Your Comment