B for Beauty

Smile Straight or Smile Crooked?

kiki dunst smiles with baby fangs.jpgOnce a month, after school, I used to walk across town to get my braces tightened by my dentist.

Dr. Cashion was a folksy man, as in, he didn’t wear gloves when he touched my teeth. I’d wait in the operating chair, listening to his assistant tell knock-knock jokes until Dr. Cashion shuffled my way. I’d inevitably bust out of there forty minutes late and speed-walk back to school, late to orchestra and suffering from my stretched jaw.

My reward for all that pain? A smile as symmetrical as college-ruled paper. Yet, I’ve been wondering lately, with the influx of crooked-teethed stars, whether it was all worth it.

“Straight teeth are bullshit,” said Keira Knightley. Amy Winehouse’s mouth looks like Stonehenge and Kirsten Dunst’s teeth aren’t exactly picture perfect. Of course, best of all is Chuck Bass’ crooked grin. It’s not like these people can’t afford perfection but rather they’re saying, “I threw my retainer in the trash and you’re going to like me regardless.”

The problem with braces isn’t that they’re one more symbol of unnatural beauty, not that they cost thousands of dollars and not that once removed the changed teeth often return to their natural state, but that braces are also, when forced on children, unethical. They make kids’ gums ache for years and cut up their cheeks. “It’s like forced plastic surgery for children,” says my straight-toothed friend Josh - without anaesthesia, of course.

“I was totally obsessed with my two front teeth being straight from ages 12-19,” says my friend Tamzin, who had braces twice. “Then the second time they went back to being crooked, I said, fuck it - it’s not meant to be.”

So embrace your crooked smiles, don’t force your kid to get braces and admit it, you want to make out with Chuck Bass, British teeth and all.

—GLENNA GOLDIS

Comments

avatar
1

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 3:39PM

honestly, a crooked smile on a guy is a huge turn on for me.

avatar
2

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 3:40PM

I think it's great that some people go "au naturale" with their teeth, foregoing braces.

However, I don't think it's an unethical act for a parent to opt for braces for their child. Sometimes it's about dental health -- if the teeth aren't growing in properly and are crowding out other teeth, I see no harm in getting it corrected. (Note: Wisdom teeth removal is similar; I had to get mine removed or else they'd have created problems for my other teeth, in terms of crowding.)

I'm all for natural beauty, and I'd definitely get braces again. My teeth were only straightened -- not replaced, not given ceramic caps, not zapped millions of times with laser whiteners. Just. Straightened. Agreed, they pull back to their old direction (the muscles in your gums "remember" the old position and will still guide your teeth) but hey -- that's why I wear my retainer once a week, and had a permanent retainer (small wire) put on the back of my front two teeth.

Just wanted to say I don't feel I should be called out as some slave to "unnatural beauty" because to me, braces aren't a purely cosmetic issue. I think it's more about overall dental health.

avatar
3

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:16PM

I love this post! My parents forced me to get braces in the secound grade to close the gap between my two front teeth. I was most dissappointed that my favorite water gun was being destroyed (I used the space to shoot water through, very efftive! lol) after my braces came off, I had a perfect smile but I refused to wear my retainer at night, as it was uncomfortable and my gap returned in smaller fashion. My smile now resenembles Madonna and although in my teen years I wished I had kept my perfect smile and even considered veneers, I'm sure its my gap that led to my short modeling career cause to be sure without it I look a little too generic.

avatar
4

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:19PM

Sorry fashionista, you've reached a new low. Braces=child torture? I don't think so. Amy winehouse as someone we'd like to look like? I think not. Reach a little higher ladies.

avatar
5

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:20PM

I totally agree with guest #2, I had braces due to my mouth being too small and overcrowding of my teeth.
I think braces are not unethical at all.
I like that these celebrities are going au natural, its more appealing than the stark white abnormal veneer look!!

avatar
6

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:21PM

Honestly, it depends on the severity of the crookedness. Before I could even start on braces I had my upper jaw expanded, i.e. cranked apart every morning. My canines were practically sideways and I could fit a full sized straw between my two front teeth. All of my lower teeth were crowded forward and jutting out when I opened my mouth. I had four extra adult teeth that had to be pulled. Yes, it was painful, but I knew even at the age of 10 that if I didn't have braces I would face a lifetime of dental woes. My parents gave me something they can never have (and have never let me forget it ;D).

7

posted by fashionursta

Dec 15, 2008 4:24PM

I feel your pain. I too had braces as a kid, but you should have seen where one of my front teeth was (on the roof of my mouth!) But there is another reason for straightening out teeth, and it has nothing to do with a perfection. When teeth are crowded or very crooked, there is much more of a chance of tooth decay due to the accumulation of plaque that hides in the unnatural crevices that crooked teeth tend to produce. Plaque can lead to gum disease and tooth loss, and it is also linked to heart disease. So that should be the main reason for correcting crooked teeth. And you can stop just short of perfection. I still have a slight overbite, and I LOVE my husband's overbite, he looks so cute when he smiles!

8

posted by fashionursta

Dec 15, 2008 4:24PM

I feel your pain. I too had braces as a kid, but you should have seen where one of my front teeth was (on the roof of my mouth!) But there is another reason for straightening out teeth, and it has nothing to do with a perfection. When teeth are crowded or very crooked, there is much more of a chance of tooth decay due to the accumulation of plaque that hides in the unnatural crevices that crooked teeth tend to produce. Plaque can lead to gum disease and tooth loss, and it is also linked to heart disease. So that should be the main reason for correcting crooked teeth. And you can stop just short of perfection. I still have a slight overbite, and I LOVE my husband's overbite, he looks so cute when he smiles!

avatar
9

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:31PM

#4, I'm going to guess you didn't have them. While it may not be unethical, it definately is painful. I had braces for 6 years and can not begin to discribe the throbbing headaches that would follow every appointment, not to mention the pain in my mouth that would make eating anything other than soup impossible. Then there was the torture of having them tightened with strange tools that resembled the tools in my fathers garage! Every appointment had tears...
I love this post and it definately made me look at my crooked smile a little differently. Yes, crooked, after 6 years of braces it took less then 6 months for my teeth to shift! :)

avatar
10

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:39PM

I'm 23 and just got braces (ten months left to go). My parents never thought that my teeth were a problem but I became super self conscious about them. I wish that my parents had taken care of the issue when I was younger so I wouldn't have to be dealing with it now...and yes it is super painful especially after appointments! I am so happy to be doing it now though and the pain is totally worth it to me. I do have many friends that have had to have braces for a second time due to not wearing their retainers...I will definitely not make that mistake which I probably would have had I had them earlier in life.

avatar
11

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:44PM

The braces conversation aside, his name is Ed Westwick.

I find it a little silly you tag him as his American alter-ego instead of his British self. Nice.

avatar
12

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:47PM

There are many reasons that braces are recommended that have nothing to do with esthetics. As a current dental student I am a little appalled at this entry.

13

posted by abby_kate_lee

Dec 15, 2008 4:47PM

heck yea I would not think twice about making out with Ed Westwick, British teeth and all! I wore invisalign retainers for about a year, thinking I would have a perfect smile and now a couple months later my teeth are no longer perfectly aligned and gapless. such a rip off those invisaligns are!

avatar
14

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:57PM

I never had braces despite a front-two-teeth-gap. My mother endured 60's braces pain and refused to put us through them despite the vast improvements in care in the 30 yr gap. Though my dentist reminds me they can easily be fixed everytime he looks at my teeth, I love my little gap. It's my smile's charm and individuality that makes me keep turning him down, not pain, ethics or anything else.

avatar
15

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 4:57PM

Hey whats all this about British teeth. What u proberly dont understand is that growing up in the 70's and 80's in England not as much emphasis was placed on cosmetically enhancing our teeth! Yeah we went the dentist and we looked after our teeth but we didnt question the ones we had unless they were really really bad! So lay off.

avatar
16

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 5:23PM

I love this post!

avatar
17

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 5:23PM

It’s a cultural thing. In Britain emphasis is put on maintaining healthy teeth, rather than achieving the perfect smile. It’s not that we don’t like the ‘Hollywood smile’, or that we all love the heroin-chic, tobacco stained Pete Doherty/ Amy Winehouse look. It’s because most of us grow up with NHS dentists whose first priority is health! Ed Westwick isn’t kooky and Keira isn’t making a ‘statement’…

avatar
18

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 5:31PM

What a terrible post. I can't believe Glenna Goldis didn't publish this anonymously. I can't believe this was allowed to be published at all!

Your argument is a slippery slope. If you sincerely believe that orthodontic work on children is "unethical," does that mean children with scoliosis shouldn't be "subjected" to "corrective procedures"?

This post is completely preposterous. You can't refer to celebrities and then prescribe dental and parenting advice to the rest of us. Who do you think you are? And if this post was supposed to be light-hearted, well, I don't think it's appropriate here because you completely undermine our parents' efforts to give us the gift of straight teeth. It's very disrespectful to your readers.

Find something better to write about so you don't come off as a spoiled ingrate.

avatar
19

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 5:34PM

Rule Britania!

avatar
20

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 5:44PM

#4, i love amy! i honost to god think that a smile that dosn't look "picture perfect" adds alot of personality. there are beautiful models in magazines who have far from "perfect" teeth.

avatar
21

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 5:51PM

Vision of Keira, Ed, Amy et al organising a mass throwing away of retainers, Camden maybe. Only cool kids allowed.

avatar
22

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 6:00PM

Good lord. Guest number 18, and others:

Chill.

It's a fashion blog. Not academic research. Not the Bible.

And on the point, if you think this is a slippery slope, anything can be a slippery slope. The point of slippery slopes is using your brain/judgement, i.e. knowing when to stop. Dental work to prevent major problems, jaw issues, horrific torment at the hands of peers for abnormally awful cases: good. Painful procedures for the sole purpose of forcing your kid to adhere to a ridiculous and unnatural societal standard because you want your kid to be "perfect": stupid. And selfish.

I had braces, but as a teenager, not a little child... I never wore my retainer, so my teeth are still crooked, but they were REALLY bad before. However, every single one of my younger brothers (5 of them!) have been recommended braces, and none of them have particularly bad teeth. These dentists want business; they don't want your health and best interests. Use some common sense...

avatar
23

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 6:02PM

i don't think anyone should get braces...because I have naturally straight teeth and I want to get the pretty points for it, and with all the fake straightened teeth, no one notices!

avatar
24

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 6:15PM

Due to overcrowding, my mother-in-law lost most of her teeth by the age of 20. My son inherited the same problem, I guess if it's considered torture, so be it; at least he will have teeth in his mouth to chew his food with.
BTW: aren't we lucky to live in a country where there is dental care readily available, with or without medical insurance?

avatar
25

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 6:23PM

#22: "It's a fashion blog. Not academic research. Not the Bible."

Do you mean to say that fashion is inherently superficial?

avatar
26

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 6:24PM

I’m not sure whether this is true but I was told that during the 60s dentists in Britain were paid per filling resulting in our parents and grandparents being given unnecessary fillings (and apparently traumatising the nation!). This press called it ‘digging for gold’ and might explain why today’s British youth are reluctant to have work done unless absolutely needed.

27

posted by adora

Dec 15, 2008 7:16PM

And then there are the people like me, who have perfectly straight, white teeth without wearing braces. Yay good genes.

28

posted by adora

Dec 15, 2008 7:19PM

Oh, and by the way, if you're so proud of your freakishly crooked teeth which have "character," how come you almost always smile with your mouth closed, Kiera/Kirsten?

avatar
29

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 7:24PM

When I was younger, I had a large gap in between my two front teeth. As I grew, the gap began to gradually close. By the time I finished university, I had perfectly straight, gap-less teeth that could've been an orthodontist's wet dream (minus the crazy amount of money).Even now, I'm asked how long I wore braces for.
Part of it is genetics, part of it is just letting nature take its course.

I remember Tom Cruise getting braces a few years back and I couldn't understand why. His teeth don't look much different now.

avatar
30

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 8:31PM

Eh, sometimes braces are necessary. My little brother first started going to the orthodontist before he even had all of his adult teeth because his mouth was in such bad shape. Now at 13 he has perfectly straight teeth. But if they had just been left alone? Ugh I can't even imagine haha his teeth were growing on top of each other.

I, on the other hand, didn't really need braces but got them anyway because I wanted them. I like straight teeth.

avatar
31

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 9:17PM

I like crooked smiles. I also (weirdly) think crooked teeth are kind of attractive (to an extent!)
I had braces, and my teeth look good but I honestly don't think the nightly headgear was worth it. I didn't have huge problem in the first place.

avatar
32

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 10:04PM

ugh! i hate crooked teeth. Maybe its just cause my father is a dentist and i've grown up around teeth, but there is something creepy and gross about crooked (and yellow) teeth to me. Its the first thing i notice when i see someone new, and its definetely a huge turnoff, at least for me! I mean, a couple a crooked teeth no problem, but when your teeth are as crooked as Katie Holmes', i get a little disgusted and can't even look at her.

avatar
33

posted by guest

Dec 15, 2008 10:29PM

I have had braces twice, two retainers and have had 13 teeth surgically removed as well as had my palet cut open. All in the name of straight teeth. And even after all of this, I am so grateful everytime I look in the mirror!! Even after having my braces removed more than 6 years ago now I still thank my mum regularly.
http://midnightravel.blogspot.com/

avatar
34

posted by guest

Dec 16, 2008 12:13AM

I couldnt disagree more. I am so blessed my mother spent the money she did on my teeth, andI dont regret at all the years as a kid I spent in some pain, or social awkwardness. My teeth look great and I am more confident now. Not everyone can pull of the crooked smile. A slight off tooth/teeth is one thing, but some people have terrible grills, that they then have to later in life get fixed. Which is more traumatic, kid braces or 4o year old braces?

avatar
35

posted by guest

Dec 16, 2008 12:16AM

i just had orthognathic surgery (wikipedia it). it cost my parents 30g. was it worth it? hell yes. for the first time in my life, my teeth are perfectly straight, and i love them. i'll wear a retainer (at night) for the rest of my life, because i'll be damned if these babies move after what i've been through...

avatar
36

posted by guest

Dec 16, 2008 12:25AM

I never had braces, I just have 2 very slightly crooked teeth. Sometimes I hate them but no one has ever not been attracted to me because of them that I know of. One of my guy friends has the cutest gap tooth ever, it's so endearing, and ironically he is a pre-dental major! My boyfriend had braces, but he hasn't worn his retainer and he's getting a bit of a gap, and I'm excited, haha.

avatar
37

posted by fay

Dec 16, 2008 4:12AM

I like that these celebs aren't bowing to the pressure to be "perfect" and have braces just to make other people happy.

avatar
38

posted by guest

Dec 16, 2008 4:29AM

i like this article too... i always suspected it was just a huge scam, like the way pharmacuetical companies keep pushin their pills on us!

39

posted by Emi

Dec 16, 2008 9:42AM

Love this post!! Braces be darned!

40

posted by cesarcmma

Dec 16, 2008 12:27PM

LOL...I just came from my appoinment...LMAO

The problem it's bigger than estethical tell ME about it... I got braces a year ago (two years to go) and all the pain it's been worth it...after a week with them I was surprised on how changed was my smile. I wish my mom would have done it when I was child because for not doing it now I have to go through 3 years of treatment, and a surjery to correct the damages my crooket teeth did to my jaw...but I know all of this would be worth it and I'll definetly will wear my retainers at night...and if I ever have a son or daughter I'll make sure they grow up with straight smiles.

avatar
41

posted by guest

Dec 16, 2008 12:46PM

This post is so true! I've been a big fan of Kirsten since I was a kid and her teeth are one reason I like her, she won't do anything about them even though she's probably been asked. I've had braces and I don't think they helped at all and I gotta say it hurt like hell when they put them in! And no eating gum or other stuff that sticks to them for months. What a waste of time...

avatar
42

posted by Ericka

Dec 16, 2008 2:11PM

I love this post!

avatar
43

posted by guest

Dec 16, 2008 2:12PM

wait.... your orthodontist didn't wear gloves?!?
haha, GROSS.

I'm so so so thankful for the braces that my grandparents got for me. Sure, they were painful and quite frankly sucked, but nothing beats having the straight smile you dreamed about before braces. I would definitely say that my pretty smile is one of the reasons I'm so confident!

(and as for child torture... I don't really hear any of the kids who had to wear braces rebelling against their parents claiming that they ruined their lives for straightening their teeth... just saying)

avatar
44

posted by KLW

Dec 16, 2008 4:26PM

Kristen and Keira, as it has been pointed out, generally smiled with their mouths closed or else so show-offy and wide open that you're too busy checking out their tonsils to see their teeth. "Chuck Bass" is sexy because of how he broods, not because of how he smiles. And all these people are incredible genetically blessed in other ways. Most of us have enough other minor imperfections that having our teeth fixed hardly leaves us cookie-cutter, supermodel perfect, no? But I guess it's easier to tell us to love a little gap in our teeth than it is to tell us to love the cellulite on our thighs and rock it out in some hot leather leggings.

Also, I underwent incredibly costly and painful dental implants as well as braces, and would do it all over again in a second. Given the choice between "generic" and "freakish gaping holes in the front of my mouth," generic is a better look for most people

avatar
45

posted by guest

Dec 16, 2008 4:43PM

With regard to the dentists recommending braces for young children - they're not trying to rip you off.

If they can get the teeth to grow in straight and create adequate space in the mouth while the child is growing and the teeth are growing in, this can mean, much, much less time (and pain) in braces and other contraptions in your teens. It can also mean you don't have to remove sets of permanent molars.


There is a big difference between a couple of slightly crooked teeth and severe problems. My teeth were straight and looked great, but my jaw used to lock up - can you imagine an emergency trip to the dentist because you can't get your jaw shut?

46

posted by hannah

Dec 17, 2008 6:33AM

This is funny because I've grown up in a upper-middle class town where braces are basically a "necessity" for every kid. I did not really need braces--I just had a few crooked bottom teeth and a slight overbite--but I insisted on getting them anyway (this was middle school, after all) and I didn't find them excessively painful. And while I may adore Lara Stone's teeth, in real life excessively crooked teeth tend to gross me out; I just can't help it. And when small kids have braces, it's because they have serious dental issues; you can't get them cosmetically until age 10 or so because you don't have your permanent teeth. "Unethical"? Haha no... maybe a bit painful and expensive and perfectionist but they aren't really that bad.

One positive thing is, that while the stigma of bad teeth may have gotten worse, the stigma of having braces is practically gone. I've never heard anyone called "metal mouth" or "train tracks."

Yes, it is funny how Keira always has a closed-mouth smile....

avatar
47

posted by guest

Dec 17, 2008 1:25PM

There is a huge difference between a crooked smile and crooked teeth. Actually, my gripe is more about those porcelain veneers smiles, just un-naturally HUGE teeth. Then as you get older the skin sags around the mouth and they really look like false teeth.

avatar
48

posted by guest

Dec 17, 2008 6:59PM

i am british with perfect natrual teeth!

avatar
49

posted by guest

Dec 17, 2008 7:00PM

i am british with perfect natural teeth!

avatar
50

posted by guest

Dec 18, 2008 1:17AM

#2 - very well said!
#33 - oh myyyy. glad that you're happy, though!

This is an interesting post...I never noticed that Keira's teeth were a bit crooked! I had braces from fifth to seventh grade and most of my friends have had braces at some point in their lives. I'm really glad that I had those braces because crooked teeth was just ruining me. My permanant teeth grew out crooked (and yellow!) after knocking out two of my baby teeth from tripping and falling on my mouth. As they grew crooked, my face also got crooked. I also didn't take care of my teeth very well...I had a huge sweet tooth and got plenty of cavities.

After getting braces, my face has realigned (sounds like plastic surgery, I know) a bit. Also, my dentist made me brush my teeth after I ate and although he didn't tell me to floss, I started doing that, too. Six years after I got my braces off, my teeth are still pretty straight and I wear my retainers most nights. I was never against having braces and I think I always knew I was going to get them since my teeth were just soooo crooked. It hurt a lot, yeah, but it was worth it!

avatar
51

posted by guest

Dec 18, 2008 5:53AM

I personally think that perfect teeth(and white) are way better than crooked teeth...
I do not like Keira Knightley, plus her problem isn't her teeth it's her jaw...

avatar
52

posted by guest

Dec 18, 2008 8:59AM

i had braces when i was ten and my teeth still have the biggest space between them... they don't work

avatar
53

posted by guest

Dec 19, 2008 2:46AM

This was really fucking pointless. And quite sad.

avatar
54

posted by guest

Dec 25, 2008 3:47AM

what kind of sources are "my friend so and so" are you in high school?

Post Your Comment