B for Beauty

Trend Test: Sulfate-Free Shampoos

fekkai au naturel shampoo.jpgWhen it comes to our hair, many of us are what can be politely described as crazytown. We like our hair to look and feel a certain way and get really bitchy when our strands don’t comply. And since the natural boom, we’ve gotten even more exacting as to what’s actually in those products, or more specifically, what we don’t want them to include: sulfates.

The sulfate debate has been raging for years. If you’re still a little hazy on the details here’s the rundown: Sulfates are a chemical that serves as a lathering and cleansing agent in everything from shampoos to body washes. They are cheap and effective but they are pretty harmful to the environment and are known to strip hair of color and natural oils.

I choose my products based on how good they make me look and feel, unfortunately not solely for their impact on the earth. That said, if there are areas in my life where I can go green without sacrificing efficacy, I do it. So naturally, when I saw that three of the major players in the hair care biz — L’Oréal, Frédéric Fekkai and Jonathan Product — were finally launching their own sulfate-free shampoos, I tried out all three brands to see if they could outperform my regular stuff.

The results:

—MEGAN MCINTYRE

I started off with the Jonathan Product Green Rootine Shampoo. It has a foam consistency that kind of freaked me out. I had to keep checking the bottle to be sure it was indeed a shampoo and not a mousse. I wasn’t a huge fan of it simply because I didn’t feel like I was getting enough on my strands, and hence, wound up using way too much of it. My hair looked clean but it still felt oily to me.

Next up was the L’Oréal EverPure Moisture Shampoo, which felt kind of heavy on my hair in the shower and sure enough, when I was finished blowdrying, my hair was hanging a little limper than usual. I definitely got some shine though and my hair did feel clean. If you’ve got really full hair, this might be more up your alley, but I don’t recommend for fine hair.

Finally came the Fekkai Au Naturel. It was love at first lather for me.

The shampoo went on light, suds-ed up nicely and made my hair feel clean. The end result was super smooth, shiny hair that had lots of body and movement. The $23 price tag did cause me to pause, but this is one of the few lines I’ve found that completely satisfies my every hair care demand to a T, something I think is worth plunking down a little bit extra for.

So what do you think, are you going to make the switch to sulfate-free, or are you sticking to your usual shampoo no matter what the green experts say?

Comments

avatar
1

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 9:56AM

I use PureOlogy products and their shampoos and conditioners are also sulfate-free. And amazing.

avatar
2

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 10:57AM

I got the Fekkai Au Naturale shampoo and conditioner in the gift bag at the Rag & Bone show, and I am so happy with it too. Alas, Fekkai is always expensive.

avatar
3

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 11:11AM

I agree with the above comment, PureOlogy is GREAT!! IDK how much I would trust Fekkai..I always used sulfer free products since I got brazialian straightening

avatar
4

posted by workandgirl

Apr 01, 2009 11:22AM

long ago, i used the ken paves sulfate free line sold at walgreens. i loved it, and it was well priced. i wish i could still find it - as it did wonders on my hair and my wallet.

and since i know i can pay that price for sulfate free, i'm not shelling out $23 today.

5

posted by Megs252

Apr 01, 2009 11:38AM

This one?
http://www.beauty.com/bal/templates/brand/default.asp?brand=57882&aid=336064&aparam=ken%20paves%20healthy%20hair&scinit1=ken%20paves%20healthy%20hair

I tried it and wasn't a huge fan. It worked fine, I've just had better results with other lines, both sulfate and sulfate-free.

avatar
6

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 1:17PM

which pureology shampoo is it?is it less expensive than the fekkai? if so, i think id like to give it a try..

7

posted by Megs252

Apr 01, 2009 1:44PM

Guest 6, what's your hair type? Pureology has tons of different lines for different types. If it's fine like mine you might want to try the Pure Volume line. If it's damaged you should try their new Essential Repair line which is amazing. I wish I could use it more but it makes my hair so flat. Soft and reconditioned yes, but still flatter than I'd like.

Unfortunately they are also pretty pricy in the $25-$29 price range. A somewhat cheaper sulfate-free option that I'm big on is the John Masters Organics Lavender Rosemary Shampoo
http://www.johnmasters.com/nhs.htm

It's $16 and works like a dream and smells really pretty to boot.

Anybody else have any other cheaper sulfate-free suggestions? I only highlighted these brands because they are new to the game, there are tons of quality brands out there that have been around for years producing quality cleansers without sulfates. Let's hear some more products!

8

posted by mpw

Apr 01, 2009 2:15PM

Are there any sulfate-free brands that are particularly good for colored hair?

9

posted by Megs252

Apr 01, 2009 2:28PM

Technically anything without sulfates is better for colored hair because it won't fade your color quite so fast. Pureology has based their reputation on being specifically for color-treated hair and it's a well-earned reputation. They have all these great ingredients in there that work specifically to keep your hair color looking its best.

avatar
10

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 2:29PM

Pureology's tagline is "serious color care". Is is a sulfate-free brand designed for color treated hair with an anti-fade complex. They have several different variations, such as hydrate, moisture, volume, etc; It is supposed to be a salon only brand, but you can find it at Ulta, Target, Walgreens, etc. It smells great and there is a deep conditoner for each line as well as styling products.

avatar
11

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 5:44PM

I just want to point out that not all things with sulfates are harmful. For example, Epsom salt can also be called magnesium sulfate. It's sulfates attached to carbon chains which are harmful, not all things with sulfates.

avatar
12

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 7:28PM

megs252, you are awesome!thanks for all the info!!

avatar
13

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 11:14PM

I started using abba shampoo. It's vegan and sulfate free. I really like it.

http://veggie-hair-products.com/

avatar
14

posted by guest

Apr 01, 2009 11:56PM

Frederic Fekkai Hair products changed my life, I am a devotee.

avatar
15

posted by januhhh

Apr 02, 2009 12:18AM

i think everyone forgets about the people with oily hair. i have tried a lot of shampoos and conditioners that claim to tame oily hair, but to no avail. by the end of the day my bangs are still awful. anyone have suggestions for oily hair? something that really works?!

avatar
16

posted by guest

Apr 02, 2009 9:38AM

I too have oily hair and am a devoted fan of the Purelogoly's volumizing line. Gets rid of the oil yet perserves my highlight and even gives my hair a lot of bounce. I highly recommend it.

avatar
17

posted by guest

Apr 05, 2009 8:33PM

oily hair: dry shampoo will change your life. They sell a purse size one at sephora and it really does wonder to touch up oily bangs midday...

avatar
18

posted by guest

Apr 07, 2009 12:13AM

veggie shampoos take time for your hair to get used to. like around 2 weeks. oiliness is normal.

Post Your Comment