B for Beauty

Are You A Product Snob?

chanel lipstick make up snob.jpgMajor magazines have major closets - one filled with shoes, one with bags, one with clothes and one positively overflowing with beauty products.

Those beauty products get cleared out with major sales, up to four times a year with the proceeds going to charity, and I used to run them. I’d get an almost sick thrill from watching which items the editorial staff attacked. It could be the ugliest shade of bright orange lipstick, but if NARS ran its way down the side in bright white letters or interlocking C’s sat at the bottom, I’d place all my money on a Manolo beat-down.

The interns and I watched with eyes agog as usually composed women dived across tables for YSL foundation two shades darker than their skin, while less expensive but still amazing brands languished on the table.

Sure, everyone has their favorite brand, but there’s a fine line between brand loyalty and snobbery. I may be addicted to Kiehl’s, but I won’t ignore the recently launched Olay products on my desk. In fact, some of my favorite new products come straight from Duane Reade: Bioré Skin Preservation, L’Oréal Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara and Aveeno’s Nourish shampoos and conditioners.

There are plenty of brands that have earned their reputations by producing both efficacious and innovative products, there are also a lot of brands that create less than great products that ride the fashionable celebrities-love-it wave which defeats the purpose of any product.

When you’re shopping for products is it about the brand or do you actually research the product behind the label? Furthermore, are you loyal to one company or is your medicine cabinet home to every brand under the sun?

—MEGAN MCINTYRE

Comments

1

posted by Jac

Jun 08, 2009 11:42AM

i made the mistake of using clinique's dramatically different because I bought into the brand. = months of skin problems. Now i research everything on makeupalley. i've found that most brands can do something really well, but none of them do everything well. some drugstore products are great too.

2

posted by Megs252

Jun 08, 2009 11:49AM

I had the same problem with Creme de La Mer. I had heard so much about it that when I first became an editor and a jar made its way to me, I started slathering it on regularly. One week later my skin was so broken out it was humiliating.

My problem was I didn't stop to think that the Miracle Broth, while working wonders on dry skin, would cause my oily skin to go bezerk. I was so wrapped up in the hype I didn't bother to take my specific skin needs into consideration.

avatar
3

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 12:13PM

Not exactly related-- I love the beauty posts on this site. What was the super easy black eyeliner pen that was posted about a few weeks ago? I kind of want to track it down...

4

posted by nycshoegal

Jun 08, 2009 12:25PM

#3 eyeliner gel was Bobbi Brown. I have it. not bad at all but actually not the easiest to apply in my opinion. you have to buy the brush for it separately and i'm not crazy about the one BB sells.

as per the post - sticking with the brand name when it comes to beauty is just silly.
i have only 3 products i will never replace - MAC concealer, NARS blush in Orgasm and Physician's formula powder and bronzer. Yes, Physicians Formula costs on average $12 at a pharmacy and they are amazing - i literally have people stopping me on the street to ask what is it i'm wearing on my face.
As far as skincare, i vote Avalon Organics. Affordable, found at Whole Foods, and works great.

5

posted by stylecrusader

Jun 08, 2009 12:28PM

For me its just really a game of trial and error. I used to be somewhat of a product snob but i've let that go and truly believe that drug store products (sometimes) are just as good! Lately i've been LOVING maybelline makeup, their water based foundation, mascara, matte powder get the trick done flawlessly. sometimes I still go for the lancome mascara though! But as of late I've been using almost all drug store products aside from my YSL touche eclat, Chantecaille lipgloss

avatar
6

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 12:51PM

My price point could be anywhere from $5 or $45. Depends on if it works.

7

posted by lauraloveslagerfeld

Jun 08, 2009 12:53PM

I'm a product snob when it comes to what I put on my skin, but when it comes to mascara i think Maybelline do some of the best! I am a massive fan of M.A.C for all other areas, and Barry M for nail polish as they do so many colours and they don't chip like Chanel.

8

posted by bastylefilegirl

Jun 08, 2009 1:01PM

While I do have some high priced beauty items i.e. NARS, Kiehls etc, I also mix and match with drugstore items so by no means am I a beauty snob. My favorite mascaras is by Maybelline, and I noticed that L.A. Girl ( 1 dollar to 2.50) and E.L.F (1 dollar) nailpolish last wayyyyy longer than the more exspensive brands.

avatar
9

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 1:24PM

I use a pretty equal mixture of both drugstore & more expensive makeup brands. But I'm a total Maybelline whore. I absolutely love their mascaras and their Mineral Power line is honestly the best thing that's ever happened to me.

avatar
10

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 2:05PM

Great post! :-)

avatar
11

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 2:11PM

I'll drop a lot of money on brand name face wash (Fresh), & concealer (Laura Mercier) - both of which were recommended to me and are fantastic - but bronzer, eyeshadows, etc - all the stuff I change often is usually drug store, so I don't feel too bad buying ANOTHER color. And I have no complaints regarding the quality.

12

posted by sugarshock

Jun 08, 2009 2:29PM

Like Guest #5, I used to be a product snob and favor only cult brands (that tend to have a hefty pricetag attached). I've since realized, since working as a beauty editor, that many drugstore brands are on par with, and in some cases, better than their higher-priced counterparts.
That said, a new Dior mascara or the latest YSL makeup (which is often packaged like art pieces) can still set my heart aflutter.

avatar
13

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 2:54PM

Only use my own home-made, organic or vegan products for skincare. As far as make-up is concerned, everything else is more about how well it meets my need and less about its label. Makeupalley.com is also definitely my go-to for product reviews.

avatar
14

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 3:21PM

I have to be careful buying products because my skin is sensitive. My dermatologist gave me samples of CeraVe face wash and it works for me. I still use Chanel toner, eye cream and moistuizer. Would a drugstore brand work just as well? Maybe. But my skin is in better condition than it has ever been, so I don't want to take a chance. I use a tinted moistuizer from Chanel, but eyeshawdows from M.A.C. and Dior. The only eyeliner I would use is M.A.C.'s Fluidline. I think I am a loyalist to various products, not the brand.
If it gets results, you will buy it no matter who makes it.

avatar
15

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 3:41PM

For cleaning products, I use drugstore brands. Nothing cleans without drying like Cetaphil, and I use drugstore moisturizer and kiehl's sunscreen (it doesn't clump). But colors, I love chanel and ysl and won't wear any foundation except for armani (the only brand i've ever found that makes something pale enough for me).

avatar
16

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 4:17PM

i like to use higher end better mixed concealer and foundation because drugstore brands are often terrible on my skin or do not cover enough or a whole other host of problems. but things that are trendy or will only be good for a month or two i buy at a drugstore (mascaras, lip-glosses, nail polish, eyeliners etc.)

avatar
17

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 7:03PM

haha i know what you mean about beauty sales. i have to admit i'm guilty of grabbing expensive makeup that is definitely not something i'd wear. but i always do know someone who would, and it makes a nice gift! when really shopping, i stick to drugstore brands.

avatar
18

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 8:21PM

I love Kiss My Face! (a local brand located in NYS!) and other natural brands like Alba, Aubrey orgnics, Welda, etc. being natural and good for my skin is more important to me than the label

avatar
19

posted by guest

Jun 08, 2009 9:32PM

MAC is my go-to source for lipstick but I love Laura Mercier for tinted moustrizer, benefit & Nars for for powder blush, Korres for eyeliner pencile.

My skincare is just as varied: Olay, Neutrogena, Origins and Nature's Gate all co-exist in my medicine cabinet.

avatar
20

posted by guest

Jun 09, 2009 3:11AM

i really like your writing style Megan , keep up the good work :-)

21

posted by austinsamuel

Jun 09, 2009 5:25AM

Clinique fucked me up as well, would never go there again.

La Prairie on the other hand, I'd be rubbing it between my toes like Karl Lagerfeld if i could afford it, ha

avatar
22

posted by guest

Jun 09, 2009 6:39AM

Most of my skin products aren't name brand. But I always buy Dior Mascara and YSL lipstick, because they work and look fabulous.

avatar
23

posted by guest

Jun 09, 2009 4:55PM

Like in most of the other posts, I use a mix of products. I tend to use higher-end foundation and concealer because I am also very pale and its tough to find a good match (I use Shiseido foundation and Laura Mercier concealer).

I do lots of research on makeupalley.com and check ingredient lists religiously. I recommend Alpha Hydrox (cheap but high quality glycolic acid-based skincare line), and second the love for many of the inexpensive natural/organic brands. I just use what works for me and my budget. Just do your research and buy from places where you can return or where they will give you good samples.

avatar
24

posted by guest

Jun 09, 2009 8:02PM

i think it's a little weird that we take "product snob" to mean someone who only uses department store brands--can't a snob just be someone who is snobby about their products and who not willing to change because of they think their products are better? Whether it's the price we pay, the vegan/organic/all-natural ingredients we like, or the effect we get, I think we're all snobby about our products in a way; just look at how many women like to gab about their products.

Post Your Comment