Racked wants to know if you think Scarlett Johannson’s new Mango ads are creepy or beautiful.

We want to know if she’s wearing Phillip Lim’s SS10 resort lace dress, or an identical copy Mango‘s reproduced for their fall collection. We’ve been staring at it all day and we can’t tell.

The Lim dress is one of the best white lace dresses we’ve seen for under $1000. Teen Vogue‘s Mary Kate Steinmiller wore it so well during Fashion Week, Lily Aldrige wore it to the Grammys and we’d wear it way too often. It probably sold for around $600.

Mango’s looks like a fantastic rip-off and it’ll probably cost about $200. But we’d bet the other $400 that it won’t look like it does on Scarlett when it hits stores at the end of the summer. Click through for a closer look.