News
M.I.A. vs. Lynn Hirschberg, Part Two: Audio Recordings and French Fries
By Matt Creamer
A few days after responding to a scathing profile by Lynn Hirschberg by posting the writer’s phone number on Twitter, M.I.A. is once again taking aim.
This weekend, on her record label’s website, the pop star released a couple of low-quality audio snippets of the interview, one of which gave a bit of context to a quote where Maya — M.I.A’s real name — waxes revolutionary while nibbling on an expensive snack.
Here’s the quote:
“I kind of want to be an outsider,” she said, eating a truffle-flavored French fry. “I don’t want to make the same music, sing about the same stuff, talk about the same things. If that makes me a terrorist, then I’m a terrorist.”
As profile-writing goes, it’s subtle and kinda brilliant. Problem is, the recordings, titled “War Crimes and French Fries” and “Here’s the Truff,” reveal that Hirschberg sort of pushed the fries on a poor, unsuspecting Maya, promising that The New York Times would be footing the bill and urging she should get whatever she wants. It’s now clear that Lynn was REALLY into getting the fries.
While the episode should be sort of embarrassing for Hirschberg, who is moving on to become Editor At Large at W Magazine, it doesn’t exactly vindicate Maya. In the rather long profile, titled “M.I.A.’s Agitprop Pop,” Hirschberg gives us plenty of reason to not buy wholly into the M.I.A. persona. Throughout the course of the piece, Hirschberg suggests Maya is exploiting an incendiary political situation in her native Sri Lanka to benefit her celebrity and a luxe life in Los Angeles.
Avoiding these sorts of contradictions has long been a problem for pop artists and celebrities who have used political causes as their material. The story’s cover line alludes to “M.I.A’s Radical-Chic Rap,” a reference to an awesome essay by Tom Wolfe that savaged the 1970s-era contradictions of the Black Panthers and its coterie of wealthy white supporters like Leonard Bernstein and Barbara Walters. (Here’s a link to the piece.)
For her part, Hirschberg has responded by refusing to change phone number, now exposed to the Twitterverse.
Finally, here’s Maya’s take on the fashion world:
“I am so tired of stylists,” Maya said. “They are ruining individual style. If Patti Smith was starting now or Debbie Harry, the stylists would try to dress them, to change them. Their style would be lost.” Maya, who was wearing jeans made out of denim that had been quilted into a tribal pattern and a loose crocheted top in red, wanted the Hermione de Paula girls to incorporate her ideas with their existing designs that she had seen on their Web site. “They have a jumpsuit that I like,” Maya said. “But instead of using their fabric, I want them to use a fabric that’s made from a document I found.”






The 10 Best YouTube Hair Tutorials
The 10 Best YouTube Makeup Tutorials
Fashion's Most Stylish Guys Give Mark Zuckerberg an (Almost!) Hoodie-Free Makeover for Facebook's IPO
Style and Substance: 10 Ladies Who Have Proven You Can Have Both
10 Beauty Boards You Should Be Following on Pinterest
I love MIA. I have always considered her to be a brilliant artist. Remember that her CD hits stores this June. Any publicity is fabulous and now is the time to get it! She's a smart girl. I don't understand why the media has made it to be such a big deal though. just another thing to keep us distracted from living our own lives, i guess. Fashionista is most definately one of my favorite distractions.. MIA too.
In Lynne Hirschberger's last profile, of Megan Fox, there is an almost identical quote about Ms. Fox saying something vacuous while eating truffled french fries. I smell a stich-up.
i love you m.i.a., but don't get so miffy about this stuff. with your fiance's fam, the rest of your life is going to be spent sharing all your opinions over really expensive delicious meals while people smile and nod and don't know what to make of it later.
Wow, I wonder which clueless digital/social media marketing agency MIA's people hired to leave these comments. Lime? Cornerstone?
Sounds like the article writer here thinks the Hirschberg piece is credible just because it already confirms his beliefs. So, Hirschberg massages the facts – but nevermind
Sorry, but Team Lynn. Maya's 32, way too old to be Twitter Feuding with anyone and abusing the caps lock key as much as she does.
In terms of dissonance between personal story vis a vis public persona, Lady Gaga, Beyonce, and other current pop stars easily rival MIA — and yet it seems most paramount to The New York Times to expose MIA as a fraud. I doubt we will be treated with similar stories about Beyonce's conservative leanings until she hitched her wagon to the Obama's — but then again, she is very diligent about playing into group think for financial gain.
I was reading that too! Either way, it's important to focus on what is being said, with context taking a backseat. Regardless of whether or not they ordered fries for themselves or they were pushed on them, fries as a food do not typically induce out-of-character quotes.
“As profile-writing goes, it’s subtle and kinda brilliant. Problem is, the recordings, titled 'War Crimes and French Fries' and 'Here’s the Truff,' reveal that Hirschberg sort of pushed the fries on a poor, unsuspecting Maya, promising that The New York Times would be footing the bill and urging she should get whatever she wants. It’s now clear that Lynn was REALLY into getting the fries.”
It's not subtle, it's certainly not brilliant, and by your own admission, it was a setup.
I'm glad Hirschberg is leaving.
“MASSAGES the facts”? It sounds like she engineered the situation. Don't you realize how easily that could happen to any interviewee in the presence of a hostile interviewer?
What kind of journalistic standards do you have?
I don't know this artist's work, and I'm not interested. (BTW, the Wolfe piece does not sound comparable. He was making fun of limousine liberals, not of the Black Panthers, of whom he was probably afraid.)
But Hirschberg's previous work has left a terrible impression. She seems retaliatory and petty: bad traits in a journalist.
I'm sorry. I was tired and didn't catch your sarcasm.
Exactly right.
I don't know this artist — she sounds like a typical pretentious airhead. But if as a writer you indict a subject for hypocrisy (she says she cares about the little people while tucking into truffle fries) and you urged her to order said Marie Antoinette-ish fries, that's a form of entrapment.
Interviewees typically are trying to impress interviewers or to create some kind of image. If the interviewer manipulates the situation, that could well prompt statements that otherwise might not have been made.
Of course, some people don't care. They just want (possibly false) drama.
I know that feeling of finding something you really love and finding out that it’s at a price you can afford. You’re not sure if your heart is going to beat so hard your chest will explode or your heart will stop beating all together.
MIA trades on the fact her pa was a low-grade terr'ist and makes pretentious political dance music for young hipsters who wouldn't know Sir Lanky from Madagascar 2.
That being said, if Lynn Hirschberg ever offers me truffle fries, I'm going to tread carefully.
Hmmm…I like Mia…and I think she has a great style…we shouldn't judge her ….
visit http://www.iscariotteh.wordpress.com
^ So what if she has great style, doesn't disregard that she's rambling on her music for her country, when I know all I listen to is the beat? Not much she actually doing for on a couple of borrowed beats, catchy phrases.