Every Monday after a hot summer weekend I giggle to myself at the ridiculous tan lines and scorched necks circling around me on the subway. But perhaps this is a bad time to mock. I am about to embark on an extended beach trip, so who knows what sort of damage I’ll do to myself. Last summer I ended up with a cleavage burn. Not sexy.

The National Cancer Institute predicts that there will be more than one million new cases of skin cancer in the US in 2010. Despite being bombarded with scary statistics like this, I still see an awful lot of girls with gorgeous cafe au lait skin wandering around. And yes, my eye is still trained to think it looks good. I can’t help it. Mind you, it should be a golden tan–think Gisele–not a nuclear one (Hi, Snooki!).

I long ago gave up tanning. I’m blonde and pale, worried about cancer, and also exceptionally vain. Wrinkles, are much worse than pale skin, you know. So I valiantly apply my SPF 75 and have embraced my porcelain hue.

I’ve never tried tanning products, though I was briefly tempted by those tanning salon misting machines. Then a I saw a friend come out looking like a pumpkin.

A company recently sent us a self-tanning gadget to try, but I couldn’t bring myself to use it. I’m usually game for testing out gimmicky jeans or putting any sort of goo into my hair, but a home airbrush tanning machine? It’s just weird.

The box states, “Airbrush tanning is not a dye. The primary ingredient in the tanning solution works with the amino acids in the top layer of your skin to produce a natural tan exactly like the sun, but without damaging your skin.” All I could think of was Jeff Goldblum in The Fly and my DNA mixing with some strange chemical.

I still sometimes look longingly at the bronzers in Sephora, but for now I’ll rock my paleness and celebrate the natural look.

If your skin isn’t naturally tan thanks to genetics and ethnicity, what color are you right now? And how’d you get that way?


Fashionista in your inbox

Subscribe to our free email newsletter and get the best fashion, style, and beauty news and tips.

Most Popular Stories

Comments [39]

I am super duper Scotch pale. My skin is practically translucent. My three summer essentials are Clarins liqued bronze, Avene SPF 50, and Vichy Normaderm Pro-matte with spf. The Clarins is so intense I could only use it once every 5 days or so, but after the first day it's a really natural tan, with that radiant quality that Gisele was somehow born with.
To deal with my heat and sun sensitive skin, the Vichy Pro Mat is a revelation. I can walk downtown for hours in sweltering humidity and my forehead is still bone dry. It almost makes me want to stop passersby on the street to show them my forehead.

Right now I'm just a tiny bit tanner than my normal paleness, having just returned from a visit home to San Diego. Growing up in Southern California I was constantly surrounded by extremely tan people, but I've always gone for an airbrush tan. Not the mystic booth type, but the kind that is sprayed on you by a technician. They adjust the color for your skin tone, and no one has ever suspected that my golden tan was fake.

I am mixed race, between Caucasian and African American, so I'm naturally tanned. I never fake-baked, but I saw people who do. Like you said, they look like a pumpkin. The strange thing about it is that they think they look good. Well, the girls that I went to school with thought they looked good. The natural golden color that one can get from a little bit of time in the sun looks fine. It's the florescent orange from a tanning booth that looks crazy. Why not save the money and spend some time at the beach?

Also, I agree with you on the wrinkle thing. When I get my first wrinkle, it will be the end of the world.

I'm half Italian, half Dutch, so I always have a little bit of tan.

I don't sit in the sun very often, but when I do, I sit in it for half an hour, without using protection. It seems really stupid to do so, but I read that if you use SPF, the vitamin D from the sun doesn't enter your body.

If I decide to sit in it for more than half an hour, I use SPF 50. But girls (and guys), if you worry about wrinkles, you should look on the product. It should say it protects also from (age)damage caused by UVA rays. UVB causes the sunburns.

I'm a redhead and try and rock my super pale look year round. I rarely wear anything above 15spf and haven't had a sunburn in years.

But if I'm vacationing or having photos taken a get a good airbrush tan (about $45 where I live) and it lasts about a week. It's essential to find a real pro, though; a tan last week left me looking splotchy and ridiculous. Otherwise I LOVE airbrush tanning, and would get them every week if I could afford it. Fingers crossed that the fumes don't give me cancer someday.

I have a runner's tan. It's tragic. It's kind of like a farmer tan except for the line around one wrist (my watch), and lines on my thighs (shorts) and ankles (socks). I slather myself in gobs of sunscreen every time I go out, but within 15 minutes I've sweated it all off.

Hahaha! I hear you. I am on week 4 of marathon training and have the same stupid watch tan. This is despite sunscreen application every single day.

This post really makes me appreciate my lovely brown skin! Thanks :-)

I live in Greece. I wear 50 SPF everyday and still find myself with a tan. My skin tans easily but really, there is just no place here to hide from the sun. It is strong and everywhere.

I embraced my paleness as a teen and haven't looked back. I haven't had a sunburn in nearly 20 years and my skin is all the better for it. I do get a few snarky comments in the summertime, my favorite: the wrinkled nose followed by “You're so pale!” (oh so observant and original, your parents must be so proud!) But then your heart melts when someone describes you as “luminous porcelain” ( I wanted to marry you, handsome stranger!) Plus I think pale is so chic!

The new MyMyst spray tan booths are much better now than in years past. You can choose from four shades so if you go with the lightest, called “Glow” it's a very light, natural application. The next step up is “light” – it looks good but I shudder to think that there are two more darker shades. I always wonder if it looks normal but friends ask if I've been basking in the sun or been on vacation. I live in Austin so lots of people are v v dark (and a bit dry and pruny, if you ask me). I don't need to look like Malibu Barbie but a very light glow in the summer is nice.

I'm really in love with the at home spray on tan, more specifically the Sunlove brand. It's cheaper than having it done by someone else and it looks so much better than using lotions.

So I'm happily and safely rocking the tan this summer.

I'm really in love with the at home spray on tan, more specifically the Sunlove brand. It's cheaper than having it done by someone else and it looks so much better than using lotions.

So I'm happily and safely rocking the tan this summer.

I am French so I have very light skin and dark hair. I love the contrast that it gives so I have never gone tanning. My mother used to lay in the sun all the time and now she is worried about skin cancer, and even once went to a tanning parlor and one of the lights exploded. I guess things like that have made me frightened. I keep my color by staying out of the sun when I could, and I always use La Roche-Possay Antihelios lotion. I am quite fond of my paleness. Natural tans are lovely on the right people, and fake orange ones are never a good thing.

I am originally from California and have been living in NY for 9 years. When I go back to visit, my friends and peers have aged from their sun exposure. Along with looking young, my main motive to not tan is having lost my father to malignant melanoma two years ago. I faithfully put on sunscreen.
I used to do Mystic Tan a while back, but have stopped not knowing what toxins my skin absorbs from it (mystic tan does not disclose the ingredients).

I'm a relatively fair-skinned black woman. I don't like lying in the sun for long hours so I've never been a big on sun tans. Once I went to Mexico on vacation and, as a personal challenge, wanted to see if I could get as dark as some of the people there. (I love their coloring). But my skin ended up shiny and crinkly and soon began to peel.

This shouldn't be news in 2010, but people of color can get skin cancer and need to use sunscreen.

I think that many Caucasians with deep tans look cooked. I can't believe they think it's attractive. And then when you consider the enmity towards individuals with naturally dark skin the obsession with tanning is infuriating.

Not all French people have light skin and dark hair. Some are of African origin.

“The end of the world”? I would buck, because everyone eventually gets wrinkles.

“buck up”

Also, give your sunscreen a good look over. Studies are finding that many sunscreens accelerate skin cancer. A newly popular ingredient in sunscreens is retinyl palmitate, an ingredient that makes skin more sensitive and can cause a photochemical reaction with sun exposure, allowing the sun rays to penetrate deeper into skin's layers…not surprising since it is in the same family as retin-A. Vitamin A (retinyl palmitate and retinol) should not we used with sunlight.

EWG has a great healthy sunscreen guide. What to buy and what to avoid.
http://www.ewg.org/2010sunscreen/

I''ve got very fair translucent skin that doesn't really tan and I burn horribly painfully. So I love sunscreen, hats, and shade. I've tried artificial tanning but it looks terrible on me, either too orange or too dull so it looks more dirty than tan. I get some comments in the summer about how pale I am and that I need to get outside more which is frustrating. I've known too many people in my family who've had to have moles removed and biopsied to take any chances.

I guess she is talking about herself.

Im asian and cool-toned pale. A lot of westerners have this misconception that asians want to emulate caucasians so we try hard to lighten our skin but in fact its because loong ago in asia the rich stayed indoors and the poor were outdoors farming and were naturally much darker than the rich.

These notions are still loosely held (i.e. tanned female celebrities are deemed 'sexy' and 'exotic' whereas pale female celebrities are said to look 'royal' and 'classy').

Anyway aside from this I am worried about wrinkles so I try to keep out of the sun and wear SPF products all the time. I really enjoy my pale skin and dark, jet black hair… :D

french as an ethnic group, and not as a nationality, i believe was meant.

tanning vs. being naturally dark skinned is not the same thing when it comes to colorism. Completely unlrelated, as is lip injections and booty injections.

Hahaha — I did the same thing on a trip to Jamaica, initially just wanting to even up the coloring on my legs. I fell asleep in the sun and woke up with a second degree sunburn, which I vociferously denied to my boyfriend at the time because “black people don't get sunburned!!” For the rest of the trip, I had to walk around in baggy clothing with a bottle of aloe vera, and when I got back to the states, my doctor read me the riot act on skin cancer.

I have to work in the rice paddy about 10 hours a day to keep my awesome tan.

It's ok Cheryl, your paleness is more appropriate against the black Alex Wangs you wore tonight.

Yes, I was referring to ethnic French, descendants of Gauls. I was born outside of Paris and lived in the city for 25 years before coming to New York so I am aware that there are other ethnicities that are French nationals. African, Chinese, Turkish, etc. You do not have to go to make me look foolish. My wording must have not come though properly, forgive me for English not being my native tongue.

I love healthy sunny skin…It just looks great….chic…expensive…glamorous…

visit http://www.iscariotteh.wordpress.com

before donning a bathing suit a slathered my entire body with clarins self-tanner (all r good) for 5 days straight so that when i did venture into the light i didn't look like an albino whale. i only “sun” for about 1.5 hours a week and use a 50 sunblock. mid-week i use shiseido brilliant bronze quick self-tanning gel; it dries almost immediately and does not stain clothes (totally rocks). i look tan all summer long with minimal damage.

A little bit of Vitamin D every week is crucial to health:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/27/health/27brod…

Sorry to sound like the Grim Reaper, but you may like to take a look at this very sad story of Asian- Australian Claire who died of skin cancer at the age of 26 after using solariums to get a tan prior to a holiday, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_KmHEJXYZrQ.

So funny!!!

Not. Anas-void. Rasho: i know you fervently believe the misconception Jaimes is talking about (the whole westerners thing), but guess what, you *might* be wrong. Did you even think the whole rich/poor thing could be a valid possibility before rushing off to make an inane comment crafted to point out the archaic status implications of Jaimes' explanation? Guess what? Tons of standards of beauty (as well as fashion) are related to what they convey about status, not solely the look itself. Wake up and shut your mouth before making yourself look like a jerk AND a fool.

i'm italian, so if i avoid the sun i stay quite pale, but i tan easily and naturally. honestly, i use dove gradual glow lotion (something like that, can't remember the actual name) or the juergens stuff. i love that shit. if i use it every two or three days – honestly, whenever i remember – i never look fake. i don't smell weir, and my skin doesn't have that translucent look to it. also, a bit of color can really help hide the random imperfections on the legs one tends to acquire when one is 22 years old and clumsy when intoxicated.

I'm pale and I'm proud of it. Pale is the new tan far as I'm concerned. I don't tan, I BURN. Besides that, my paternal grandmother died of a brain tumor that actually started as skin cancer. For vitamin D I can easily take supplements.

I don't even find real tans attractive and don't understand why anyone would. Let alone the Oompa Loompa look.

A common look i’ve seen is girls with tannish orangey skin and dark hair. They’ll dye it either jet black or a dark chocolately brown…who do you think you’re fooling? Nobody thinks you’re from Brazil honey. You’re white. Fucking deal with it. What’s so bad about being pale anyway? lol. I’m dark skinned by the way

lol @ the end of the world. Hahaaa definitely. And yes, thank you Nemo for giving us some of your knowledge! Everyone eventually gets wrinkles? =O Thank goodness you told me!

Look at how people of dark skin used to be treated. Not just black people, people who looked different enough from whites. Now so many light skinned people want to darken their skin! Purposely! It’s HILARIOUS! NOT completely unrelated. Wtf?