When Chloe Moretz’s LOVE issue six cover was revealed last night, we joked that if the next cover ended up being Hailee Steinfeld we wouldn’t know what to do with ourselves. And, of course, it is (does this mean I’m psychic or was it super obvious?). As you can see, Hailee, too, is crying and wearing white lace, with some amazing rhinestone cuffs (to match Chloe’s devil horns?). We also love Hailee’s natural, wavy hair and I’m dying to know what that lipstick is.

Click here to find out who the rest of the cover girls are. And click through for a side-by-side of all three. Which one will you buy?

**Photos via Models.com