Rodarte, Prada, Honor…Some of our favorite labels–and ones we don’t often see at awards shows–made an appearance on the red carpet at last night’s Critics’ Choice Awards, and boy was it a treat.

From Diane Kruger’s Prada gown from Spring 2012 (one of our hands-down favorite collections of the season) to Elle Fanning’s Rodarte ensemble, last night’s dresses were surprisingly high fashion. Cross your fingers that the red carpet keeps moving in this direction!

Click through to see our top 10 looks.

All photos: Getty