Religion has been a theme of many a fashion editorial, but it’s rare that a magazine with as broad a reach as W would publish two similar stories in a three year span.

W’s November 2009 issue, branded the art issue, featured Linda Evangelista doing her best Virgin Mary impersonation. Come 2012, W recycled their “Holier than Thou” motif with an editorial featuring Kate Moss with a cross between her legs.

Which iconic model does religious icon better?