Jessica Biel and Justin Timberlake’s Italy nuptials may not have been exactly royal (thought celebrities are the closest thing we’ve got to royalty)–but Biel’s pink Giambattista Valli gown did bare a striking resemblance to a certain royal wedding gown. And no, we’re not talking about Kate Middleton’s Sarah Burton-designed gown. We’re talking about the pink confection Lisa McDowell (aka Shari Headley) wore to wed Prince Akeem Joffer of Zamunda in Coming to America.

So now the question is: Which would you rather? Sure, Biel’s was designed by one of the more talented couture designers out there–but Princess Joffer’s has what looks like ten pounds of tulle! And a diamond-encrusted headband! And she’s a princess!

Who do you think the sartorial winner is here? And would you ever wear a pink wedding dress? Weigh in please!