Last night’s episode of Girls may have been called “Boys” but the girls gave us plenty to talk about outfit-wise. Especially Marnie, who wore a very confusing see-through dress made out of vinyl. It was the second time in one season that Marnie and Hannah had to ask each other what they were wearing.

Save for Marnie, we feel like every character stayed very true to themselves this episode. Read on for our thoughts. Oh and spoilers, obvi.