Adventures in Copyright

Photo: Regretsy

Fast fashion retailers often get accused of stealing other designers’ work, but this case is a bit different. H&M is being accused of stealing an original design from the work of a East Atlanta-based artist, Tori LaConsay. Tori emailed Regretsy to point out that a sign she had painted in 2008 as a love letter to her “tight-knit” neighborhood was swiped by H&M and subsequently used on things like bath towels and door mats. The items in question were sold on the UK’s H&M site (see above), but we don’t see them there now, not surprisingly.

LaConsay wrote to complain to H&M and got he following response from a customer service rep: “We employ an independent team of over 100 designers. We can assure you that this design has not been influenced by your work and that no copyright has been infringed.” After that, she sent her tale to Regretsy and H&M has now responded to the controversy via social media. Read more »

There’s nothing so synonymous with Brit label Fred Perry as the laurel wreath. Hell, it’s been their logo for sixty years–the brand first stamped the symbol on their famous polo shirts in 1952. So imagine our surprise to find the above left cream-colored sweater for sale, not on Fred Perry’s site, but at other Brit label Topshop’s. Read more »

Photos: Getty, Jason Wu

Douglas Hannant and Jason Wu share a similar design aesthetic and clientele (classy, high-end), but do they also share similar designs? The NY Post is reporting that “sources” noticed that a look from Jason Wu’s pre-fall 2012 collection was strikingly similar to a Douglas Hannant frock that Anne Heche wore in September. Read more »


Rihanna, Rihanna, Rihanna: When are you going to learn to stop ripping off photographers’ work?

In October, the songstress settled out of court for an “undisclosed sum” with David LaChapelle over her S&M video, which allegedly cribbed directly from his work–and she faced another lawsuit from photographer Philipp Paulus over a scene in the same video, which was undeniably similar to an editorial he shot a year beforehand. But, from the looks of her latest video “You Da One,” Rihanna has even more legal troubles ahead of her. Read more »

derek-lam-ivanka-trump

Yesterday Derek Lam sent Ivanka Trump Footwear a cease-and-desist letter requesting Trump stop selling her ‘Cadie’ wedge sandal, which Lam alleges “blatantly and intentionally copied” his Ayami wedge sandal. To glance at the two shoes, there’s no doubt about it: they look identical. “It’s such an investment to make a shoe…we had to protest this,” Jan-Hendrik Schlottmann, chief executive officer of Derek Lam told WWD.

But Marc Fisher, which produces Ivanka Trump Footwear, is refuting Lam’s charges. How?

Read more »

On the left is a Spring 2011 ad campaign for David Yurman featuring a bed-headed Kate Moss sultrily lifting her fingers to her mouth to show off the jeweler’s rings. On the right is an ad campaign for the supermodel’s line for Fred showing a bed-headed Kate Moss sultrily lifting her fingers to her mouth to show off the jeweler’s rings. Uh oh.

And the similarities don’t end there. Kate Moss’ Fred campaign features a number of photos that seem to crib directly from the model’s Peter Lindbergh-shot campaign for Yurman last year (check out the other comparison shots below–the similarities are glaringly obvious). Read more »

Left: Carven; Right: H&M

H&M Spring 2012 collection has lots of punchy colors, structured silhouettes, and a jacket we swear we’ve seen somewhere before…Ah, that’s right, we have! Because Carven put out the exact same jacket for spring 2011.
Read more »

Photo: Splash via Frockwriter

Say what you will about Kim Kardashian, but the girl shows up for work. She touched down in Sydney yesterday with sis Khloe to promote the launch of a line of Kardashian Kollection bags exclusive to Australia (the designer/entrepreneur the sisters worked with on their Sears kollection, Bruno Schiavi, is a Sydney native). Only, maybe her head’s not all right following her filing for divorce and the entire world calling her marriage a sham, because instead of karrying Kardashian Kollection to promote her line, she was snapped carrying Balenciaga.

Funny choice of designer, actually. One of our favorite Aussie fashion writers, Frockwriter, points out that one of the bags in the Kardashian Kollection handbag range is an obvious Balenciaga knock off. Of course, it’s not the first time the Kardashians have been accused of knocking of a handbag. Monica Botkier sent a cease and desist letter to Sears after the Kardashian Kollection knocked off her 2009 ‘Trigger Clyde’ bag.

Balenciaga on the right, der

As we took a look through the Kardashian Kollection’s Australian handbag line we noticed a lot of other heavy “inspiration.” Read more »

Alexis Bittar‘s expertly-crafted jewelry is nothing if not unique. The time and care put into each piece is evident just by looking at them (or reading the paragraph-long descriptions on his website). The same cannot be said of the Kardashians’ design oeuvre.

So we were not exactly shocked this morning when we read that Alexis Bittar is accusing Kim Kardashian, to whom he has loaned out jewelry on multiple occasions, of copying his designs for her Belle Noel jewelry line. (It wouldn’t be the first time.) He tells the Post,

In the reality TV world, there are so many people coming out with lines to capitalize on their TV shows. They are not designers and they are just stealing. I passed the Dash pop up store on Broadway, and I saw that Kim’s pieces were very similar to mine, and she definitely has been taking note (of my designs). The tricky thing is that we have sent pieces to Kim in the past to wear, so now I have told my staff we cannot send anything to her. She was definitely influenced by my designs without a doubt.

Was she?

Read more »

Jessica Rogers of SomedayNewYorker work on the left. Nicki Minaj at Carolina Herrera on the right.

Earlier this week, Nicki Minaj made headlines when she sat next to a soberly-dressed Anna Wintour, wearing a rainbow, shoulder-pad-dress-concoction completely covered in neon pom-poms, at Carolina Herrera’s Spring 2012 runway show. Everyone had a good laugh, and prasied Minaj for her gusto and originality…except that, as it turns, the hip-hop singer was wearing a flagrant rip-off of another designer’s work.

Young designer Jessica Rogers, 21, of SomedayNewYorker, has been producing garments nearly identical to Minaj’s–which both the singer and Rogers refer to as “Puff Ball” style–for almost three years now. What’s more, Rogers tells us that Nicki Minaj‘s stylists had contacted her in the past about using some of her clothing–among them a Puff Ball dress–however once Rogers sent further images of her work, she never heard back from Minaj’s team. Rogers said she even followed up a month later, sending more images of her puff ball garments, eager for the prospect of working with such a big-name star.

But it seems like Nicki Minaj–or more likely, her stylist–had different plans, copying the vulnerable young designer’s work without so much as a mention. “When I saw the photos [of Minaj at Carolina Herrera] I was in tears,” Rogers said. “I’ve worked very hard to make my dream of being a fashion designer come true. I have built contacts with Teen Vogue, Gaga, Katy Perry, and Marina and the Diamonds has worn my garments. [Now,] I feel like everything has crumbled down.”
Read more »

We’re not exactly surprised Steve Madden ripped off Miu Miu–actually the mass retailer has already done it before–but we are a tad taken aback that they’ve chosen to copy this shoe in particular. Read more »

To no one’s surprise, fast-fashion juggernaut Forever21 has just been named in another copyright-infringement suit, this time at the hands of eco-conscious, indie label Feral Childe. Again, to no one’s surprise, the print in question, pictured above left, does indeed look identical to Feral Childe’s original Teepees print, above right.

Actually the only surprise is that, sadly, given Forever21‘s track record for winning suits, the retailer may get away scot-free–But not if Eliza Starbuck has anything to say about it. The Brooklyn-based designer started an online petition with Change.org to help ensure Feral Childe’s pleas are heard. Yesterday, we caught up with Starbuck to ask her how she got involved, and why she thinks this time, Forever21 might actually listen.

Read more »