How Drunk Elephant Founder Tiffany Masterson Went From Stay-at-Home Mom to Beauty Mogul

She built one of the fastest-growing skin-care brands in Sephora's history.
By Stephanie Saltzman,

In our long-running series, "How I'm Making It," we talk to people making a living in the fashion and beauty industries about how they broke in and found success.

Tiffany Masterson, the founder of buzzy skin-care brand Drunk Elephant, never wanted to be an entrepreneur. "My mom was a stay-at-home mom and had four children, and I really just wanted to do the same thing," she tells me over the phone from her hometown of Houston, Texas, where the company is now based. Yet she now runs one of the fastest-growing skin-care brands in the industry — one that has shoppers, investors and competitors taking notice. 

Drunk Elephant's impressive sales and rapid growth since its launch in 2013 have caught the attention of major beauty corporations — it was rumored that Estée Lauder Cosmetics Inc. had an interest in possibly acquiring the brand — and investors. In March of 2017, Drunk Elephant received funding from private equity firm VMG Partners and Man Repeller's Leandra Medine, among other backers. 

But more crucially, Drunk Elephant is finding resonance with consumers. Its messaging, which talks about "clean" products that omit certain ingredients Masterson has deemed dubious, has struck a chord and set the brand apart on the crowded skin-care shelves. TLC Sukari Babyfacial (one of my personal favorites, which I wrote about in February of last year) was one of Sephora's best-selling products of 2017 — no easy feat for a relative fledgling stocked alongside household-name brands backed by industry giants. 

With brightly colored packaging and a quirky name (Drunk Elephant refers to the intoxicating-like effect its hero ingredient, marula, has on elephants that consume it), the company has also found success on social media, with a highly engaged community of followers. And for Masterson, it's only the beginning. New products, global expansion and yes, perhaps an acquisition by one of those aforementioned major corporations — just not anytime too soon — are all on the horizon. Read on for the highlights from our interview.

Tell me about your background and how you first got interested in skin care.

I have no background in the industry and I never envisioned myself being an entrepreneur. My mom was a stay-at-home mom and had four children, and I really just wanted to do the same thing. But around the age of 40, I started getting antsy. My children were going to school full-time, and I started looking for a way to make a little extra money.

I started selling a bar cleanser. My brother and his wife had a store, and somebody introduced them to this cleanser from Malaysia and offered them the exclusive distributorship for North America. They weren't interested, but my brother-in-law in Colorado was. He purchased the distributorship for the bar and I started selling it in Houston. I'm building awareness, and I started getting attention for the product. I got it in Harper's Bazaar. I got attention from [direct-to-consumer product company] Guthy-Renker. I started learning more, and this process ignited a passion in me for understanding ingredients, how our skin responds and which roles ingredients play in formulations. Why do some have fragrance, why do some have essential oils? What about chemical [sun]screens versus physical?

Related Articles

Cult-Favorite Skin-Care Brand Drunk Elephant Just Got a Major Investment

Panacea, A Gender-Neutra, K-Beauty-Inspired Brand, Wants to Change Your Approach to Skin Care

Infrared Saunas Are Fashion's Most Instagrammable Wellness Trend

How did you eventually get to the point where you were starting your own company?

Eventually, two years in, I figured out that the bar I'd been selling was a multi-level marketing scheme. Around the same time this happened, Beautypedia came out with a one-star review, trashing the bar, saying it was a fraud and that the ingredients didn't support the claims at all. The guys that sold it to us had told us that it was their formulation and that it was patented and secret — and we believed them. But I saw the thing with Beautypedia and that really stung me. I realized if [the company producing the bar] lied about one thing, they're going to be lying about other things as well. So we probably are looking at a bar that doesn't really have the ingredients they're telling us it does. So I went back to my investor and I said, 'We need to shut this thing down. I want to do my own.'

I had a consultant from Guthy-Renker saying, 'I think you kind of know your stuff, why don't you do your own line? You know so much about ingredients!' [My investor] was excited to get his money back out of this thing and put it into a new line.

How did you first go about developing the new product range?

I started by making a list of the six things I think we need to have healthy skin. I wanted to do a cleanser for sure and [my investor] wanted me to do a bar. Through my research and talking to dermatologists I really believed the key things you need are a chemical exfoliant, a vitamin C [product], a physical sunscreen, an antioxidant-rich moisturizer — in this case I wanted to do an oil — and then I did two bars. That totaled six products. I sat down, never having been in the industry before, and I started researching the heck out of ingredients and I, on paper, developed my own products. They were different [than they are now] for sure.

I came up with these criteria: It has to be nontoxic or low-hazard and it has to be bioavailable, meaning able to get into your skin. I can't even say that I knew that term at the time, but I wanted it to be able to get into your skin. I wanted it to be non-irritating. 

As a result, there are some common ingredients Drunk Elephant avoids. How did you decide to exclude things like essential oils?

As I'm going along doing my research, I'm wondering about essential oils and what they're there for. I would use them on my skin and my skin would freak out. Chemical screens made me break out. That's how I went about figuring out the 'suspicious six' — the ingredients that I don't want, that I've seen people complain about. Fragrance, dyes, drying alcohol — why are they there? 

I determined that the six ingredients I wanted to avoid, which I realized were largely there [in competitors' products] for marketing. Silicones make a product feel better; dyes make a product look better; essential oils and fragrance make a product smell better; SLS is a cleansing agent that penetrates your skin and irritates and strips it.

Tiffany Masterson. Photo: Courtesy of Drunk Elephant

So you really came at it from a consumer perspective?

A thousand percent a consumer head, heart, desire, not looking at other brands at all. It didn't even occur to me to look at other brands or try to compete or copy or emulate. I had it all in my head and it was coming from my gut. As a consumer, what do I wish was out there? That's what I did. 

How did you go about actually getting the products into production and perfecting the formulas to a place where they worked?

I called some people in Los Angeles who I knew could give me some names in the industry, and I eventually landed with my chemist and I said, 'Can you make these things for me?' and I sent over the ingredient decks I'd been working on. His assistant called me right away like, 'These are already ingredient decks, are you a chemist?' I said, 'No, I'm not, I'm a stay at home mom in Houston, Texas. I just want to make these products.' She was like 'Wow, I showed them to the chemist and we think they're really interesting and different and actually really good.'

We went through, ingredient by ingredient, and we swapped out a couple that canceled each other out or that did the same thing, but the resulting ingredient decks were very similar to the ones I first wrote down for every product. At some point my chemist was like, 'You know you didn't have to do it that way. I would have just done the formulation for you, that's how brands do it.' But I learned a ton doing it that way; I will always do it that way.

What is your process when you're formulating new products now? 

To this day, I still do my formulations that way because I think it makes them more interesting. I'm into health and wellness. I look at ingredients like food, like ingredients I make a smoothie with, so I'm coming at it from a different angle and I think that keeps the formulations from being run-of-the-mill. 

What were your initial goals when you were first building the business?

My goals were kind of pie-in-the-sky: I was like, I'm going to do this product line and I'm going to sell it. Once I started interviewing people in the industry for jobs, like my manufacturer or my packaging company, I started hearing stories like, 'Oh well they also do the packaging for so-and-so, who just sold his company for $200 million to L'Oréal.' And so you start getting the idea of the path. I told my brother-in-law, 'Let's just do this line, get it into Sephora and then let's sell it to one of the big cosmetic companies.'

So that was initially a goal, right from the launch of Drunk Elephant?

Absolutely. But as I've gotten further down the path of doing this, I don't feel the need to sell it [soon]. I'm sure I will one day. I love it, it's so rewarding, it's exciting, I have an incredible team and culture. I'm still in Houston, I'm staying in Houston, I love it in Houston because it keeps me out of the industry and I don't ever want to be entrenched in that. I want to just still develop and have all of my ideas come from my gut instead of from other brands. I never want to stop questioning things. The essential oil being good for you, I questioned it, I believe it's not. We keep questioning things that we've been told for years and proving perhaps that they're not right after all.

Photo: Courtesy of Drunk Elephant

Even if you did sell, you would want to just stay on board and maintain your role in the company?

For sure. I think you have to. I don't think you can just sell something that you've worked this hard on. My heart is in it; I feel protective of it. I don't want to just sell it and have somebody come in and change things.

How and when did you partner with Sephora?

I launched it originally just on my website, a kind of soft launch with interim packaging, at the end of 2013. I started sending stuff out to editors. I had my eye on Sephora, but I wasn't really ready to send the line to them because I didn't feel like it was really ready. I took that year selling it on my website and getting feedback. I tweaked a few things, and I was getting press, so Sephora actually reached out to me. They asked me which category it should be in and I told them it was a new category: nontoxic, clean.

Then I went to Cosmoprof in Las Vegas. Sephora was there and they come by — the retailers hide their badges so you don't know who you're dealing with — but sure enough, it was them. I sent them home with product. I heard from them about a week later. They'd had time to talk about it, read about the philosophy, use it, and they launched me five months later, in January of 2015. 

How did working with Sephora as a retailer change the business?

We sold out of several of the products really, really fast. The original forecast for the year we did right away, and that was exciting and challenging. I had to learn how to get things more organized. Sephora has been an unbelievable partner, and I've been a good partner to them from the beginning, but I didn't have an interest in exploding. I didn't want to put the product everywhere. 

Some of the best advice I ever got was when I was talking to a distributor in my first year and he was talking about [getting Drunk Elephant products into] Barneys or Bergdorf's or Neiman's and he said, 'I could try to get you into these places, but where do you shop for your skin care?' I said, 'I shop at Sephora.' And he said, 'That's where it's going to sell.' That proved to be exactly right.

Photo: @drunkelephantskincare/Instagram

Drunk Elephant hasn't done any traditional marketing or paid influencer partnerships. Can you tell me about that choice?

I don't know any different. I'm a firm believer that once money changes hands, the authenticity is gone. This isn't judging other brands, it's just my own personal preference as a consumer. I blow past advertisements. When they pop up on my screen I delete them, and when they get in my face I don't like that. So when I see 'Sponsored' on Instagram or Facebook, it's a turn-off for me. Immediately it says to me these people have to pay to get attention. I don't mean to sound ugly against the companies who do it. I know traditionally marketing, advertising, paying — that's just the way it's been. But for me personally it's just not my style and I don't feel comfortable doing it, now that I've not done it for so long. 

How has Drunk Elephant used social media to its advantage, even without doing paid partnerships or activations? It seems like you use it a lot for customer feedback.

Is there a better place for me, as a founder, to get my feedback, to learn new things, to be questioned, to be challenged, to be called out, to own my mistakes, to fix them, to not be defensive? I'm on there just for Drunk Elephant — it's not to bash other brands or compete. It's to connect with my consumer. I feel like if they're spending money on my product, then they deserve to have access to me. 

I make it a point once or twice a week to pick up the phone and call someone who's emailed in to Drunk Elephant. That's the most genuine way to grow your business because they lob questions at you. You get the real-time feedback. And I can go change a package, I can go change a formulation. I can do that.  As a consumer, that's what I want in a brand, so that's what I'm going to give.

You secured another round of funding from minority investors in March of 2017 — how has that changed the business and affected its growth?

It wasn't necessarily a money-need thing, it was more of a strategy-need thing for us. It allowed us to hire an elite team of industry veterans who really can help share their experiences and guide us, so that's been major. I think people are everything, and we have a really solid, great team. It's a very colorful team that I think we all share the same values. I'm so excited for the next phase. At some point you have to know what you don't know.

What's coming next for the brand?

Global expansion and exciting new products. I don't look at trends and I don't wait, so I've already developed my products through the end of 2019. I have three launches per year scheduled; I even have one product for 2020. So that's seven more products in the can that I love, that I've named, that I use.

This interview has been edited and condensed for clarity.

Please note: Occasionally, we use affiliate links on our site. This in no way affects our editorial decision-making.

Never miss the latest fashion industry news. Sign up for the Fashionista daily newsletter.

Loading ...
Join the Conversation